Paul Murphy Demands Wider Review of on board Planala
Paul Murphy challenged the Taoiseach over alleged scandals at on board Planala, citing multiple undeclared conflicts of interest, pressure on inspectors, and questionable board appointments. He demanded the Government expand its review beyond a single board member and three specified cases to examine the board's full operations and nominating bodies.
Allegations of conflicts and pressure
Paul Murphy listed a string of alleged problems at on board Planala - undeclared conflicts of interest, inspectors' reports being disregarded to favour developers, and reports of at least three incidents where inspectors were pressurised to change their reports. He also cited the Director of Planning participating in a meeting of institutional landlords and giving them advice on applications to on board Planala.
Questions over board appointments
Mr Murphy highlighted concerns about two board appointments, including a sister of a Fianna Fáil TD nominated by the Irish Creamery Milk Suppliers Association, and the Deputy Chair who was said to have been nominated by the Irish Rural Dwellers Association at a time when that body was defunct and could not have had nominating rights.
Call for an expanded review
Mr Murphy criticised the Government's announced review as narrowly focused on the actions of one board member in relation to three specifics, calling that "simply not good enough". He urged that, at minimum, the review should be expanded to cover all operations of the board and the role of the so‑called nominating bodies.
Government response and investigation
The transcript records that the Minister has appointed a senior council to investigate the issues raised about the board member, and that a report is expected to be allowed to complete. The exchange records Mr Murphy pressing the Taoiseach on what further action the Government will take in light of the allegations.
Housing context and supply issues discussed
The record includes a wider discussion of housing policy and delivery, noting actions on social and affordable housing, voids work bringing over 6,000 empty properties back into use, targets for annual housing output, and figures on family homelessness. Rising costs from the war in Ukraine and inflation were referenced as affecting construction and supply, alongside measures on tenders and cooperative frameworks to support completion of projects and new tenders.
We publish thousands of recordings to make Irish politics transparent and resistant to manipulation. Spotted an error? Report it — together we are building a reliable archive of Irish politics.
Thanks. Taoiseach, at this stage I have run out of fingers and toes to count the number of scandals about on board Planala revealed by the ditch. We have multiple incidents of what certainly looks like clear conflicts of interest not being declared. We have a pattern of inspectors' reports being disregarded in order to favour the wishes of developers. We have reports of at least three incidents of inspectors being pressurised to change their reports to bring them in line with the interests of developers. We have the Director of Planning participating in a meeting of institutional landlords giving them advice in applications to on board Planala. You have question marks over the application, over the appointment of two members of the board, including a sister of a Fianna Fáil TD, nominated by the Irish Creamery Milk Suppliers Association, and the Deputy Chair of the board, who was nominated by the Irish Rural Dwellers Association at a time when it was defunct. It did not exist as an organisation and could not have had any nominating rights for over a year. The very latest is a story yesterday on the ditch about the Director of Planning having an issue in terms of ruling on applications that were made by her relationship to her husband. The question is, Taoiseach, what is the Government going to do about this? You have announced a review, but it is a review of the actions of one member of the board in relation to just three specifics. It is simply not good enough. Do you not accept that, at the very least, the review now needs to be expanded to include all the operations of the board, including the role of these so-called nominating bodies? I have been very clear and repeatedly said in this House that housing is the single most urgent and important social issue facing our country at this moment in time. Through the Housing for All we have provided action in terms of a very wide range of initiatives on the social housing front, on the homeless front and on affordable housing also, because access to housing is fundamental to our security, stability, health and progress as a nation. There is no doubt about that. The Government is in office for two years with two lockdowns, unfortunately, which did impact on construction, although we managed to keep quite a number of social housing projects on the go. This year we will see a record number of social houses built everywhere in the country, but we need to keep that rate going every year. I cannot comment on individual cases that I am not familiar with the detail on, but supply is the vital part of this and we need to build more houses of all types as quickly as we possibly can. That is the key intervention. We have provided the resources, that is £4 billion per annum, to enable the construction of social affordable homes. We have also, for example, taken significant action on voids, making sure that local authority houses bring their voids and empty houses back as quickly as we possibly can. Over 6,000 voids have been brought back in the last two years as a result of the Minister's initiative on that. We want to get to 33,000 a year, I think the target this year is around 24,000 and last year it was about 20,000 was achieved, given COVID had an impact on that. What is interesting is March to March, we have had the highest number of commencements ever, and that is at about 35,000. The war on Ukraine, the cost of materials, commodities and inflation is impacting, but the recently cooperative framework for tenders that the Minister for Public Expenditure announced will give some capacity to try and finish projects and enable people to tender for new projects. On homelessness, that is a very key issue for us and again, you know, the Minister has taken a lot of initiatives, particularly working with the sector and working with all the non-governmental organisations in respect of homelessness and the approved social housing bodies to do what we can to provide homes for the homeless and to prioritise in terms of housing first and so forth. The current level of family homelessness is too high at 1,308, it is 26% below the peak figure recorded in July of 2018, but it is increasing and there is a range of factors behind the homelessness numbers increasing. It is not as simple or straightforward as it sometimes gets articulated and our priority will always be to do what we can, working with the non-governmental organisations to increase the supply. Deputy Keanu Callaghan raised the issue of divestment of schools. We operate a pluralist model that plebiscites are held in different locations in terms of new schools, for example, and certainly we want to see more divestment, greater plurality, greater access and the significant investment has been allocated to each other, for example, and that will continue. The Minister has appointed a senior council to investigate the issues that have been raised in respect of the board in terms of the individual on the board. That report is important that we allow that report to complete without further comment until the senior council brings it to finalisation. The Minister of Ministry dót quo for TCN president. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. It was written in the帝 place Order by volunteering of Shukri when they opened their arms anduyor lanc ENCEMIC terms. The important painting with the vision of the accomplishments of theобossian's land and the foundation to submit the march. OfЩgaret. It is possible that we introduce our�� prêt premier to theオ серд sweetie Sdom and 알아.
Thank you for downloading 🙏
If you publish this material on social media, we would be very grateful if you tagged VideoParliament. It helps us reach more people and keep building a transparent archive of Irish politics.