Menu
VideoParliament
VideoParliament Irish politics in one place — download the app
Get app
VideoParliament
VideoParliament for Windows Get the desktop app — notifications about new speeches
Get app
Mattie McGrath urges stronger online laws, defends local press

Mattie McGrath urges stronger online laws, defends local press

Mattie McGrath spoke on 21 Sep 2022 in a second-stage debate urging the minister to pass strong legislation to tackle harmful online content. He also defended local print media in his county and Waterford, criticised media takeovers and the national broadcaster's treatment of alternative outlets, and thanked GRIP Media for its support.

Call for urgent online content legislation


He urged the minister to get the bill passed and enacted, warning of the "pernicious activity" of harmful content online. He said adults can cope but cited cases where people faced huge pressures and "some lost their lives as a result of it," and criticised companies that refuse to remove obnoxious material.

Support for local print media


He saluted print media in his own county and in Waterford, praising local outlets as an important part of community heritage. He named the Nina Guardian, the Tipperary Star and the Waterford News and Star among others and spoke of the sadness at the diminution of many local publications.

Criticism of takeovers and staff dismissals


He warned against takeovers by large companies, saying "maybe up to 14 of them" were taken over by a big company he called Kindle Armoured. He described long-serving staff being dismissed, offices closed and journalists still working from home with no sign of new premises or refurbishment.

Concerns about the national broadcaster and GRIP Media


He criticised the national broadcaster for not covering every group and for banishing those who do not "suit the narrative," and said this should be examined. He thanked GRIP Media as an independent organisation that, he said, keeps alternative voices on air, and also mentioned competition issues including TG Cahar.

Mattie McGrath — clip from statement: Mattie McGrath urges stronger online laws, defends local press (21.09.2022)

Procedural note on the debate


He proposed the adjournment of the debate; the proposal was put and agreed.

We publish thousands of recordings to make Irish politics transparent and resistant to manipulation. Spotted an error? Report it — together we are building a reliable archive of Irish politics.

Tego samego dnia All speeches from this day →

Transcript
Okay, Count Cora, thank you very much. Count Cora, I'm delighted to be able to speak briefly on this second stage, on this very important piece of legislation. It's very, very needed. I would encourage, Minister, to you getting it passed and getting it enacted because the pernicious activity that goes on, you know, with, you know, content online is just quite shocking. And us as adults can deal with it, but we've seen horrible cases in the past of you. You know, people, huge pressures and huge, some lost their lives as a result of it. So, it's long and badly needed. And some of the companies too can be quite reckless and can refuse to remove, you know, obnoxious stuff that's on it, content that's on it, and they should. So, I look forward to a day when this will be dealt with. I hope the laws will be strong enough and they will be effective and that they will be able to deal with it. But it's not an easy world to traverse. I too would like to salute print media in my own county and in Waterford and beyond as well, the local press. Very important part of our whole story and our whole heritage and our whole being. And it was so sad, you know, to see the diminution of those, many of those outlets. And we met them here last week from the Nina Guardian and salute them, Nina Guardian, the Tipperary Star and indeed, you know, all the other outlets that are there, Waterford News and Star and many others. The difference is only with our nationalists, where we have takeover there and a whole lot of publications, maybe up to 14 of them, taken over by a big company again, Kindle Armoured, quite nasty people, and sold to our offices of our nationalist newspaper and have all the staff work from home. Many of the staff with the 13, 40-year service were dumped unceremoniously, just dismissed. And this was outrageously treated. And it's a terror of what greed can do and what people that are reckless and careless and think they're sensible to no one can do. And now they have no home to work in, no office, all working from home, as everybody was during COVID. But I just talked to some journalists last weekend and they're still working from home and have no idea if they'll ever again have an office. I don't believe they will. And no building was bought in town with no sign of that being taken over or being refurbished. So we must be conscious of the workers, the great people, the reporters, the scribes, the editors, the different people that have worked there over the decades, and all local media. It's so important. And of course we have then the national broadcasters and the competition there, and the unfairness as well to that way, TG Cahar and others. And I have to thank GRIP Media. But for GRIP Media, an independent organisation, some of us wouldn't exist at all. Because if you don't, if you don't suit the narrative here, if you don't obey the narrative and fall in line with it, you're banished. That's a sad state of affairs from the national broadcaster, minister, and it should be looked into and examined. Because it ill beholds the name national broadcaster, and they won't cover every group and every talk at all at this year who have something to contribute. Mightn't suit their, as I said, narratives and everything else, but it's very important that all voices are heard. Whether it be in print media, whether it be on television, or whatever. So, I mean... Can I ask you to propose the adjournment of the debate? You can, of course, can I go on. I propose the adjournment. Is that agreed? I agree. Thank you when we're...