Mattie McGrath condemns confusion over special school reopenings
Mattie McGrath criticised the minister's handling of special school reopening decisions and the mixed messages that followed. He warned that vulnerable children who cannot do remote learning are being left behind and called for extra PPE, more testing and community support.
Reversal and confusion
McGrath recounted leaving Government Buildings after a meeting with the Chiefs, saying a decision to reopen special schools was upturned within 20 minutes. He welcomed that Eastleigh Forster, the Trade Union, advised SNAs to cooperate with a phased resumption of in-school services pending safety measures, but described the earlier mixed messages as disconcerting.
Impact on vulnerable pupils
He argued the most vulnerable pupils in special schools cannot do remote learning and are regressing without school routines and therapies. McGrath described children losing skills, having sleep problems, increased irritability and self-harming, and said many parents have contacted deputies' offices expressing frustration.
Safety measures and phased return
McGrath said he welcomed a decision announced to occur on the 20th or 21st and urged practical safety steps. He called for extra PPE, more testing for staff and families, and increased community support to enable a safer phased resumption of services.
Engagement with schools and Leaving Cert concerns
He relayed complaints from a principal in Colossal Unisic about a letter sent to principals, describing anger and frustration at its content and tone and urging meaningful engagement with schools. McGrath also suggested a broader look at the Leaving Cert, questioning the pressure of condensing years of work into short exams and saying now may be the time to review it.
We publish thousands of recordings to make Irish politics transparent and resistant to manipulation. Spotted an error? Report it — together we are building a reliable archive of Irish politics.
Minister, I know that you're doing your best, but Minister, what happened last week, and I left Government Buildings meeting with the Chiefs at 20 past 6, having been there from 4 o'clock, when I arrived to Bray, the decision had been upturned, we were assured that special schools were going to reopen, and that the leaving starts were going to be brought back, and within 20 minutes the decision was pulled, and that was utter confusion. I'm delighted that Eastleigh Forster, the Trade Union, announced that they will advise SNAs to cooperate with the phased resumption of in-school services to children, pending on a number of safety measures being undertaken, and that's very important, because you know the mixed messages have been very, very disconcerting, there are legitimate concerns from teachers and staff in special schools, who have their own health concerns and childcare issues as well, so I know it's not simple, however I welcome the decision announced today, that's going to happen on the 20th or 21st, but the most vulnerable children Minister, who attend special schools, cannot do remote learning, and are being left behind again, and we should have learned from the mistakes of what happened all during the summer, children are regressing from lack of school routines, and the therapies, which are all based within the school structure, some are losing skills, not sleeping, becoming irritable, and self-harming, due to the frustration, and I'm sure you're well aware of that Minister, have been a moon tour yourself, children have to stay indoors now, because of the weather so bad, and parents are becoming increasingly upset, and many of them are contacting our offices, and other deputies offices as well, because they are just pure, just frustrated, and children are suffering so much, and cannot comprehend really, especially children, especially what is going on in their school routine, social activities are all cancelled because of COVID, and the H2C therapies, where they're limited, they're all cancelled as well, so Minister, I know you can't answer, these questions today, but you might give me some replies to them, in writing, at a later stage, and Minister, there have to be solutions found, and some of the solutions are extra PPE, more testing for staff, and for families, and support in the community should be offered also, so I mean, it's not simple, I know, but it should, the Leaving Certion Minister, again, huge efforts were made, and if it was pulled, they were going back, so there must be more cooperation with the schools, and indeed, Minister, I was contacted by a principal in Colossal Unisic today, as a result of the letter that you wrote to our principals, yesterday, on recent days, and telling them to send them out to the pens, and they're very concerned, they're very naive, huge frustration, and anger, at the content, and the tone of that letter, from your school self, and that's a pity, and I'm only relating what I've been told, and it's very important that you would engage with these, meaningfully, and properly, and those kind of letters shouldn't be sent out, that it was the first meeting, that they had, that there were actually anger, and, and, and, and, and, and, and I, it's really expressed by teachers, about the content of this letter, so that's good to review it, so the Leaving Certion, like the CEO pints have gone up this year, so it's going to be difficult there as well, so we must have a broader look at the Leaving Certion anyway, maybe now's the time to do it, because some people do question, the cramming of everything, two, or five years work into, into just two, two hours, or an hour and a half of an exam, so maybe it was time to review it anyway, so I wish you well, and I'm a bit supportive, and we will do all the independence, but we must look at our especially, especially, especially because they're so badly needed, and it's so serious, thank you.
Thank you for downloading 🙏
If you publish this material on social media, we would be very grateful if you tagged VideoParliament. It helps us reach more people and keep building a transparent archive of Irish politics.