Menu
VideoParliament
VideoParliament Irish politics in one place — download the app
Get app
VideoParliament
VideoParliament for Windows Get the desktop app — notifications about new speeches
Get app
Mattie McGrath warns amendments risk unclear implementation for clubs

Mattie McGrath warns amendments risk unclear implementation for clubs

Mattie McGrath spoke in the debate about a series of amendments, warning they risked unclear implementation and differing interpretation. He voiced concern for clubs and bingo organisers and urged clarity of purpose going forward.

Summary of remarks


Mattie McGrath expressed worry about the amendments under consideration and their practical effects. He said lawmakers must be careful to allow clubs to continue while providing clarity, noting concern has been raised by people who organise bingo and similar activities.

Concerns about implementation and interpretation


McGrath highlighted the risk of different superintendents or officials interpreting the legislation differently. He warned that any piece of legislation can be implemented with varying interpretations and that this possibility fuels his concern about the current amendment series.

Impact on clubs and bingo organisers


The speaker reported that he and others have met many people who organise bingo and that those organisers are worried by the lack of clarity. He emphasised the need to safeguard clubs and their ability to operate into the future while avoiding unintended consequences.

Mattie McGrath — moment from speech: Mattie McGrath warns amendments risk unclear implementation for clubs (04.12.2019)

Reference to other contributions in the debate


McGrath referred to a contribution from Dr Healey Ray to support the point that caution is needed. He reiterated his unease with the amendments and called for clear, purposeful drafting to prevent confusion in implementation.

We publish thousands of recordings to make Irish politics transparent and resistant to manipulation. Spotted an error? Report it — together we are building a reliable archive of Irish politics.

Tego samego dnia All speeches from this day →

Transcript
I know Sim did that, but your Derry girl had sung all kinds of everything, it went to the National Commons No, that's what it is, that's the worry I have, as Dr Healey Ray said, I mean, we have to be very careful, I mean, we want to allow, as I said, clubs to continue and to have clarity, and have clarity of purpose in going into the future, and people are concerned, and we have met people that have organised many, many bingo, and I'm sure other parties have met them as well, so there is concern, and I know we've gone past the previous amendments, but there is concern too that you might have a different superintendent or whatever, and different interpretation can be in any piece of legislation, and the implementation of the same, so I have concerns around this amendment also, this series.