Richard Boyd Barrett: Government doesn't want to solve housing crisis
Richard Boyd Barrett challenged the government's housing policy, accusing it of serving landlords and property speculators and resisting measures such as rent controls and tenant protections. He said the government has "dropped the pretense" of solving the housing crisis and cited a White House exchange involving Donald Trump and the Taoiseach to underline his point.
Barrett accused the government of having no targets, curtailing tenants in situ, resisting rent controls and taking no effective action as homelessness figures rise. He argued ministers show a lack of energy on the issue and are planning to remove even minimal rent protections.
He pointed to an exchange at the White House between Donald Trump and the Taoiseach, in which Trump reportedly called the housing crisis a sign of success and the Taoiseach responded positively. Barrett used that exchange to argue the government views the crisis as economically advantageous to property interests.
Barrett said property speculators, landlords and developers profit when house prices and rents are high and when housing is scarce or of poor quality. He linked those profit motives to defective buildings and corner-cutting by builders- saying cost-cutting on safety and quality protects profits.
He raised thresholds that remove people from social housing lists when their income rises, including those on working family payment, leaving many trapped in homelessness or squalid, multi-generational accommodation. He described local cases in Sally Noggin and Shank Hill as examples of councils and policy failing to treat secure, affordable housing as a right.
Main accusations against the government
Barrett accused the government of having no targets, curtailing tenants in situ, resisting rent controls and taking no effective action as homelessness figures rise. He argued ministers show a lack of energy on the issue and are planning to remove even minimal rent protections.
White House exchange highlighted
He pointed to an exchange at the White House between Donald Trump and the Taoiseach, in which Trump reportedly called the housing crisis a sign of success and the Taoiseach responded positively. Barrett used that exchange to argue the government views the crisis as economically advantageous to property interests.
Profit motives and defective building concerns
Barrett said property speculators, landlords and developers profit when house prices and rents are high and when housing is scarce or of poor quality. He linked those profit motives to defective buildings and corner-cutting by builders- saying cost-cutting on safety and quality protects profits.
Impact on working families and local cases
He raised thresholds that remove people from social housing lists when their income rises, including those on working family payment, leaving many trapped in homelessness or squalid, multi-generational accommodation. He described local cases in Sally Noggin and Shank Hill as examples of councils and policy failing to treat secure, affordable housing as a right.
We publish thousands of recordings to make Irish politics transparent and resistant to manipulation. Spotted an error? Report it — together we are building a reliable archive of Irish politics.
Other speeches
Richard Boyd Barrett warns of second COVID wave, calls for nurses
Richard Boyd Barrett warns €1bn film relief leaves workers insecure
Richard Boyd Barrett on committee limits and close-contact rules
Richard Boyd Barrett: Proposes Wealth Tax to Scrap USC
Richard Boyd Barrett: Stop Evicting Family with Special-Needs Children
Richard Boyd Barrett on Aircoach cuts and public transport
Tego samego dnia All speeches from this day →
Mattie McGrath
Mattie McGrath warns hotel conversions threaten Tipperary tourism
Mary Lou McDonald
Deputy Mary Lou McDonald-- speech from 2 Apr 2025
Victor Boyhan
Victor Boyhan urges new transport police with powers of arrest
Carol Nolan
Carol Nolan presses for urgent support for Offaly special school
Sharon Keogan
Sharon Keogan demands statutory national child death reviews
Mattie McGrath
Mattie McGrath criticises hotel procurement and community impact
Transcript
It's obvious the government doesn't want to solve the housing crisis. They've dropped the pretense, they've no targets, they are curtailing tenants in situ, they've always resisted rent controls, and their homelessness figures continue to rise, they do absolutely nothing about it, they don't want to stop the flow into homelessness, they're planning to remove even the minimal rent controls, they don't want to solve the housing crisis. And the truth about the government's housing policy was revealed in the White House in the exchange between Donald Trump and Micheal Martin, when Trump said that the housing crisis in this country was a sign of success, and the Taoiseach said, good answer. I hadn't thought on that one. Now why does Trump think it's a success? He's a property speculator, he's a billionaire, he's a landlord. He makes money when house prices and rents are high, when there's a shortage of housing and when there's poor quality housing. That's how they make money. That's how the rich in this country make money. That's how the property investors make money. They have no interest in solving the housing crisis. In fact, they have an interest in making sure that we don't solve the housing crisis, because if there was a supply, an adequate supply of affordable housing built on a not-for-profit basis, they couldn't make profit. That's the simple truth. And that is why you resist every measure to address the housing crisis. Because you're there to represent the landlords, the property speculators, the developers, the Trumps of this world and their Irish equivalents. That's what your government is. That's what you're doing. And that was revealed in the White House. And you can even see from the lack of energy in the Minister's speech, read off the script, we don't flippin' care anymore. We're droppin' the pretense that we're trying to solve this. And that also relates to defective buildings, poor quality buildings, because, you know, it's profitable, isn't it, for the people who build houses to cut corners. Don't put in fire breaks, don't put in proper materials, don't check the houses in case they turn out to be defective, because it would cut in to their profits. Greed, greed, greed. And that's what Jews represent, and ordinary people are suffering. It also relates to another issue I'd like to raise, again, about the thresholds. You know now, if you're on working family payment, you're working, that can take you over the threshold for social housing. Thousands and thousands of working people, who go out, work, work hard, pay their taxes, taken off the housing list, after 10 or 15 years waiting, whether they're on a worker family payment, or just because they get a pay rise, or they do a bit of overtime, and it's gone. And they have no chance whatsoever, and they're trapped in homelessness, or trapped in squalid conditions, multiple generations living in poor quality housing. I've raised again and again and again. It also affects, actually, the attitude in councils, because they want people to live in squalid conditions, because they want to say, oh, we can't make it easy for you to have a decent house. I've been fighting cases in Sally Noggin, in Shank Hill now, people living in crappy quality housing, because you don't believe housing, secure and affordable and decent, is a right. It is a right, but the profit-hungry developers that you represent make money from it, so you don't want to do anything. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.