Paul Murphy criticises government over paediatric inquiry delay
Paul Murphy accused the Government of using the occasion of Pascal Donoghue moving on to avoid answering questions, and said paediatric care statements must be converted into questions and answers. He urged a statutory inquiry into care of children with scoliosis and spina bifida and raised concerns about a Cabinet memo he understood was expected to be signed off.
Paul Murphy opened by calling it "pretty shameless" for the Government to use Pascal Donoghue's departure as a pretext to avoid answering questions in the Dáil, pressing for a proper response from Deputies.
He said statements on paediatric care should be made into questions and answers, noting that he and others had pushed for that change at the Business Committee to allow for direct scrutiny.
Murphy reiterated a long-standing push for a statutory inquiry into the care of children with scoliosis and spina bifida, stressing the need for formal investigation and accountability.
He reported that a memo was understood to be due to go to Cabinet and expected to be signed off, but said he had heard it was not signed off at Cabinet that day. He referenced Deputy Michael Collins in relation to the matter and said questions should be permitted on it.
Murphy asked that the courtesy of a response be allowed and noted the revised schedule would maintain business. He recorded that the Taoiseach will take his questions tomorrow instead of today and concluded with the words "Goeibh maith aga, Cian Ghoorla."
Immediate accusation
Paul Murphy opened by calling it "pretty shameless" for the Government to use Pascal Donoghue's departure as a pretext to avoid answering questions in the Dáil, pressing for a proper response from Deputies.
Paediatric statements and Q&A
He said statements on paediatric care should be made into questions and answers, noting that he and others had pushed for that change at the Business Committee to allow for direct scrutiny.
Statutory inquiry demand
Murphy reiterated a long-standing push for a statutory inquiry into the care of children with scoliosis and spina bifida, stressing the need for formal investigation and accountability.
Cabinet memo status and confusion
He reported that a memo was understood to be due to go to Cabinet and expected to be signed off, but said he had heard it was not signed off at Cabinet that day. He referenced Deputy Michael Collins in relation to the matter and said questions should be permitted on it.
Scheduling and questions to the Taoiseach
Murphy asked that the courtesy of a response be allowed and noted the revised schedule would maintain business. He recorded that the Taoiseach will take his questions tomorrow instead of today and concluded with the words "Goeibh maith aga, Cian Ghoorla."
We publish thousands of recordings to make Irish politics transparent and resistant to manipulation. Spotted an error? Report it — together we are building a reliable archive of Irish politics.
Other speeches
Paul Murphy warns of ecological collapse in lakes and rivers
Paul Murphy criticises unpaid 'Job Bridge 2.0' internships
Paul Murphy: Calls for Sanctions, Criticises Government Over Gaza
Paul Murphy: Council Rent Hikes Threaten 20,000 Families
Paul Murphy warns of imminent Horn of Africa famine, urges COP27 fund
Paul Murphy warns of child poverty and rising school costs
Tego samego dnia All speeches from this day →
Rose Conway-Walsh
Rose Conway-Walsh warns Mercosur deal will devastate Irish farms
Richard Boyd Barrett
Richard Boyd Barrett: Demands Consistent Opposition to Imperialism
Richard Boyd Barrett
Richard Boyd Barrett criticises housing crisis, corporate profits
Danny Healy-Rae
Danny Healy-Rae Demands Equal €600 Support for Irish Families
Sharon Keogan
Sharon Keogan urges councils to build, criticises housing plan
Danny Healy-Rae
Danny Healy-Rae Vows to Fight Mercosur, Defends Farmers
Transcript
It's pretty shameless by the Government to use the occasion of Pascal Donoghue moving on in the world to avoid answering questions today. I also want to say that the statements on paediatric care, they must be made into questions and answers. We pushed for that at the Business Committee. There has been a long push for a statutory inquiry into care of children with scoliosis and spina bifida. I understand a memo was meant to go to Cabinet today. People were led to believe that that was going to be signed off on. But I've heard that it was not signed off on at Cabinet today. It was signed off on... Deputy Michael Collins. But that we could have questions in relation to that. Deputy Michael Collins. These are exceptional circumstances on the nomination of members of Government. Allow the courtesy of a response, please, Deputies. The revised schedule accommodates this and ensures we continue with all business. And the Taoiseach will take his questions tomorrow instead of today. Goeibh maith aga, Cian Ghoorla.