Michael Collins warns on defence spending and neutrality
Michael Collins spoke on international security and international trade, urging increased defence spending targeted at personnel and equipment and stressing the country's neutral stance. He warned against deploying defence forces to active conflict zones and criticised long-term neglect of defence personnel and infrastructure.
He said he agreed more money is needed for defence but insisted funds must be spent on improvements for the people in the defence force and on the equipment needed to bring standards up, noting that "we have no standards the way we stand at this present time." He questioned where proposed "astronomical" spending would be allocated.
He warned of serious reservations about sending defence forces to countries with ongoing conflict, even if peace talks were in progress, arguing that many peace talks do not work out and deployments could lead to loss of life for defence personnel.
He described the defence force as angry and hurt, saying successive governments have failed to deliver for their everyday living and that years of mistreatment must be addressed alongside any new spending.
He cited recent incidents to illustrate vulnerabilities - a helicopter incident where "the door fell out," a Russian ship circling the island within national zones claiming exercises that threatened fishing stocks, and unsecured undersea cables off the coast. He noted fishermen from Castleton Bear intervened to negotiate with the vessel.
On trade, he recalled that Ireland previously implemented tariffs such as VRT on vehicles from England. He said he supported the meeting involving Micheál Martin and Donald Trump, arguing engagement was necessary to resolve issues, and criticised Mary Lou McDonald's stance as wrong, also referencing the SDLP and the Alliance party.
Defence spending priorities
He said he agreed more money is needed for defence but insisted funds must be spent on improvements for the people in the defence force and on the equipment needed to bring standards up, noting that "we have no standards the way we stand at this present time." He questioned where proposed "astronomical" spending would be allocated.
Reservations about overseas deployments
He warned of serious reservations about sending defence forces to countries with ongoing conflict, even if peace talks were in progress, arguing that many peace talks do not work out and deployments could lead to loss of life for defence personnel.
Legacy of mistreatment
He described the defence force as angry and hurt, saying successive governments have failed to deliver for their everyday living and that years of mistreatment must be addressed alongside any new spending.
Recent security incidents cited
He cited recent incidents to illustrate vulnerabilities - a helicopter incident where "the door fell out," a Russian ship circling the island within national zones claiming exercises that threatened fishing stocks, and unsecured undersea cables off the coast. He noted fishermen from Castleton Bear intervened to negotiate with the vessel.
International trade and diplomatic meetings
On trade, he recalled that Ireland previously implemented tariffs such as VRT on vehicles from England. He said he supported the meeting involving Micheál Martin and Donald Trump, arguing engagement was necessary to resolve issues, and criticised Mary Lou McDonald's stance as wrong, also referencing the SDLP and the Alliance party.
We publish thousands of recordings to make Irish politics transparent and resistant to manipulation. Spotted an error? Report it — together we are building a reliable archive of Irish politics.
Other speeches
Michael Collins Rejects Two-Week Suspension After Week-Long Standoff
Michael Collins urges state apology over Whitty Island disaster
Michael Collins: Why the May 20 Registration Deadline Is Unclear
Michael Collins Calls Dáil Reform a 'Document of Destruction'
Michael Collins criticises government over housing scheme pause
Michael Collins: Warns Government Threatens Ireland's Neutrality
Tego samego dnia All speeches from this day →
Martin Daly
Martin Daly: Urges Stronger Defence After HSE Cyber Attack
Carol Nolan
Carol Nolan urges sanctions on Nigeria, calls for fuel regulator
Richard Boyd Barrett
Richard Boyd Barrett: Shock at 67,000 Young Carers, Calls Action
Sharon Keogan
Sharon Keogan to introduce bill banning energy drinks for under 18s
Michael Fitzmaurice
Michael Fitzmaurice: Challenges Means Test and Demands Carer Support
Rose Conway-Walsh
Rose Conway-Walsh warns US tariffs threaten whisky and jobs
Transcript
The statements on international security and international trade are an important opportunity for us TDs here to have our say. Over the last number of weeks and months we have had a lot of people speaking here in relation to our neutrality and our participation in what is happening across the world. The Tony recently said that he is concerned that we need to spend a lot more money on our defence. I actually agree with that, but it is hugely important that that money is spent on improvements in relation to the people that are in the defence force in this country and in relation to equipment that is needed in this country to bring us up to some kind of a standard, because we have no standards the way we stand at this present time. I would have serious reservations about sending our defence forces at any stage to countries where there is conflict going on, even if there is a peace talks, because a lot of these peace talks do not work out, and sending our small number of defence force people out there to try and negotiate and try and keep peace in those countries could lead to an awful loss of life for Irish defence forces. The defence force are angry, they are hurt out there, because they have been mistreated down through the years. I think that successive governments have failed to deliver for the defence force for their everyday living. Now we are talking about spending an astronomical amount of money all of a sudden to change things around, but where is that money going to be spent, it has got to be asked. It is not long ago when we flew a helicopter up into the air and the door fell out in the defence forces. It is not long ago when a Russian ship was circling our island within our own zones, claiming that they were going to carry out exercises that would have led to the loss of massive amounts of fish in our country. It took the fishermen from Castleton Bear to go out and negotiate with them, to get them to accept that it was not going to work. Also, the cables that are on the ground here, on the water here, off our shores, are not being properly protected. That is where we need to spend money, protecting from what is going on in this country. But also protecting outside of our coastline, to make sure that we are a nation that actually spends money on our own defence force, on protecting our own country, and that we are always accepting that we are a neutral country. I think that is the one thing that we have maybe failed down through the years, is to get that point across stronger and stronger, is that we are a neutral country. We do not involve ourselves in wars, other people's wars out there. We certainly can voice our opinions. That brings me on to the next point, which is about international trade. One thing that pointed out to me in West Cork recently, by a very intelligent man, he said, the first people to implement any tariffs in this country was Ireland. You try and bring in a vehicle from England, it is called VRT or some other fancy name. So there was no problem in putting tariffs on vehicles here, when it suited ourselves if we were to buy in vehicles. The meeting, I want to move on to the meeting in relation to Micheál Martin, which I fully agree that he was right to meet with Donald Trump, because we have no hope of resolving any issues if we stand outside the door and Mary Lou. McDonald's stance on that was wrong, I think, in the SDLP and the Alliance party also. Good morning and thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Oh, good morning. Thank you.