Mattie McGrath Urges Dismantling of Custom House to Reform Planning
Mattie McGrath spoke on housing and planning reform, welcoming the legislation while warning it will fail unless the Custom House is dismantled. He urged removal of the planning regulator's powers, the return of rezoning authority to county councils, and stronger use of section 160 powers.
He told the minister that unless the Custom House is dismantled and levelled, the rot and malaise inside will continue to block progress. He argued many housing ministers over the last 18 years have failed because powerful, unaccountable structures in the Custom House resist accountability and marginalise counter‑councillors.
He criticised the planning regulator Mr Custon, saying he "created a job for himself" by disowning land and undermining councillors and development plans. He described the regulator as power‑hungry and unaccountable and called for him to be stood down and powers returned to local authorities.
He called for rezoning and planning powers to be given back to county councils and warned that a mere name change - referencing Board Penala - will not remove entrenched corruption. He compared superficial rebrands to the experience of changing Irish Water and said a veneer will not restore effective local planning oversight.
He highlighted the failure of local officials to use section 160 powers in a local case and recounted a judicial review over Dundrum House Hotel, which led the council to admit a mistake in granting a section five. He accused developers of greed, said small builders have been denied the right to build, and warned that centralised planning decisions can kill one‑off houses and young couples' dreams in rural Ireland.
He urged the minister to tackle the "deep rot" in the Custom House, reinstate local decision‑making, and ensure elected councillors are not undermined by unaccountable boards or regulators. He warned that without these changes homelessness and housing shortages will persist and that good local planning must be protected.
Dismantling the Custom House
He told the minister that unless the Custom House is dismantled and levelled, the rot and malaise inside will continue to block progress. He argued many housing ministers over the last 18 years have failed because powerful, unaccountable structures in the Custom House resist accountability and marginalise counter‑councillors.
Criticism of the planning regulator Mr Custon
He criticised the planning regulator Mr Custon, saying he "created a job for himself" by disowning land and undermining councillors and development plans. He described the regulator as power‑hungry and unaccountable and called for him to be stood down and powers returned to local authorities.
County councils and Board Penala
He called for rezoning and planning powers to be given back to county councils and warned that a mere name change - referencing Board Penala - will not remove entrenched corruption. He compared superficial rebrands to the experience of changing Irish Water and said a veneer will not restore effective local planning oversight.
Local powers, section 160 and recent judicial review
He highlighted the failure of local officials to use section 160 powers in a local case and recounted a judicial review over Dundrum House Hotel, which led the council to admit a mistake in granting a section five. He accused developers of greed, said small builders have been denied the right to build, and warned that centralised planning decisions can kill one‑off houses and young couples' dreams in rural Ireland.
Recommendations and consequences
He urged the minister to tackle the "deep rot" in the Custom House, reinstate local decision‑making, and ensure elected councillors are not undermined by unaccountable boards or regulators. He warned that without these changes homelessness and housing shortages will persist and that good local planning must be protected.
We publish thousands of recordings to make Irish politics transparent and resistant to manipulation. Spotted an error? Report it — together we are building a reliable archive of Irish politics.
Other speeches
Mattie McGrath criticises Fianna Fáil over failed USC pledge
Mattie McGrath: Blasts Health Dept for Paying Dr Houlihan at Trinity
Mattie McGrath Warns Retained Firefighters May Strike Next Week
Mattie McGrath Proposes Village Hubs and Generator Grants
Mattie McGrath slams Appropriations Bill over cost overruns
Mattie McGrath: Defends Credit Unions, Rejects 'Copper' Takeover
Tego samego dnia All speeches from this day →
Richard O'Donoghue
Richard O'Donoghue urges developer-led infrastructure to speed housing
Brian Stanley
Brian Stanley: Warns 15,292 Children Overdue for Assessments
Carol Nolan
Carol Nolan: Calls for student fee cuts, criticises stipend payouts
Rose Conway-Walsh
Rose Conway-Walsh: Calls to Restore Local Planning Power on Housing
Victor Boyhan
Victor Boyhan: Demands Answers After Ardu Athai Housing Halt
Rose Conway-Walsh
Rose Conway-Walsh demands clarity on looming student fees
Transcript
I welcome this legislation, and I welcome you in the position. And I saw how steadfast you stood against the big industry, big business, when the time was gambling in for me. I forwarded you on that bill, but you had the resolve to stick with it. So I know, and thank you for meeting and engaging with us as well, and the briefings. Minister, well, I think you have a big task here, a monumental task. And I've said this to you privately, and I'll say it again. Unless the custom house is dismantled. So it's levelled in the war of independence. I don't mean to hurt anybody, but it has to be dismantled. And get out the rot, the cinder. Some good people in there, don't get me wrong. Many good people, but there's a rot and malaise in there, and it has to be tackled. Because otherwise we're going nowhere. We've had 7,000 or 8,000 ministers here in the last 18 years as I came in, and they've all failed miserably. Because you have an intangible, you have a situation where they feel they're all powerful, and they know it all. And they won't deal with counter-councilers or anybody else. Please ask you to do that, because if you don't, you're going to fail. I'm asking you also to, I said to you privately, Mr. Custon, the planning regulator, send him out to Donald Trump or somewhere, or send him out to whatever, Gaza, he might help someone out there. He created a job for himself. By the way, he came from the customs house all his life, or a lot of his career. He created this position for himself, and the fools in government gave it to him. And gave him the power to disown land all over the country. He undermined every councillor in the country, every councillor that worked hard on the plans, in the development plans, he undermined them all by disowning the land. There you are now trying to rezone some of that land again. He went off, he created a job for himself, and went off on a fantasy tour, power-hungry, and power-greedy, and no accountable to nobody. He has to be stood down. He's not necessary. Give the power to the county councils, give the, as they should have it, and give it to Bort Panola. Here we go again, Bort Panola. There was a lot of corruption in there, we know that. And by changing the name, we had an experience here of changing Irish water, we didn't even get clean water out of it. Not a mind to see any schemes done. Changing the name, Veneer, and I love Massamangheliga, I go knee, I love the Irish name, but changing it to, on commission, Panola, isn't going to cut the mustard. Isn't going to get out the rock, where the inspectors go down to see one-off houses, or some other small developments, and give a favourable report for the Council of Granted Planning, and the board, or whoever inside the board, unaccountable, unelected people, just throw it in the bin. That is shameful. And no one should get that power. We had visionaries here, like TK Whittier, and Sean Lamass here, in the past, and others, and they brought us a long way. We built the houses in the 40s, the 50s, the 60s, the 70s, the 80s, and the 90s. And then things went wrong, with big developers, crazy, and that custom house down there, and Ministers unable to tackle it. Ministers are afraid of it, and pushed off and fobbed off by it. So, I'm depending on you to do this. I am. There's many other issues in the Minister. The Council, where they have the powers, they don't use them. We have a section 160, a power that local authorities have. Whittier and Drugs, last count Kohler, with a situation in Tlantmel, in Dragonsgrave, where all the decent people, 200 of them met in a hall, last Friday night week, worried that a haunting cycle was being created under their noses, right beside them. And six of us then, six Cranmel Broad District members, and the Mayor, and two Rochtes members, Deputy Murphy and myself, met with the Senior Planner, Mr Dave Carnell, who was the Fire Officer, who didn't do his job when he was Fire Officer. He didn't visit Dundrum House Hotel. We asked him for 12 months to visit, he never went near the place. So now he's the planner, and he refused pint blank for the Council to initiate a 160, to stop this in his tracks. He has that power, he wouldn't use it. He was talking about courts, and that he might lose in the courts. They lost in the courts last week. Thankfully, the good people have done Dundrum, and the Heritage Group took a judicial review, and the Council had to admit halfway through it, give in, put their hands up, we made a mistake in granting a section five, to allow a greedy developer to get fatter and more money in his pocket, not on humanitarian grounds. So, the Council have the powers, and they can use them when they want to. But changing the name of Board Penala, and without tackling the malaise, and the rot, and the deep rot, in the custom house, it's wasteful, it might be a pipe dream, it's not going to happen. Count the number of housing ministers we've had here, and see all the unfortunate people that are homeless, and still on waiting lists, and languishing there, and no hope. And see if small builders have been denied, the right to build the houses, and let them off. But above all, once off, the weddings should be allowed to be carried on, and don't be allowing people in offices in Dublin, throw out good planning commissions, and kill young couples' dreams in rural Ireland. Good morning, guys.