Natasha Newsome Drennan: Farmers must not pay for EU priorities
Natasha Newsome Drennan criticised EU and Irish priorities on military spending and agriculture during a contribution to a debate on farming and food security. She called for stronger support for domestic food producers and challenged the likely reduction in Common Agricultural Policy funding, warning of consequences for farmers and rural communities.
Newsome Drennan argued that Ireland should increase support for domestic producers rather than outsource more food production to third countries. She pointed to the country’s reliance on imported vegetables and referred to Talamh Beo’s policy launch on basic income supports for local food producers as evidence of untapped potential.
She contrasted the likely 24% reduction in CAP funding with more than €300 million in taxpayer spending connected to Ireland’s EU presidency. She said farmers were already struggling and questioned the EU Commission’s priorities if military spending increases while funding for food and agriculture is cut.
Newsome Drennan said farming should not be treated as just another business expense: when farms close, the consequences include empty shelves and a generational loss of knowledge. She also highlighted her claim that each euro of Common Agricultural Policy spending in Ireland generates €1.44 in economic output for the wider rural economy.

She asked where the Irish Government’s voice had been in advocating for increased CAP funding and opposing cuts. Referring to other Fianna Fáil members’ confidence in the Minister for Agriculture securing a better deal, she said she did not share that confidence. Watch the recording to hear the full contribution.
Food security and local production
Newsome Drennan argued that Ireland should increase support for domestic producers rather than outsource more food production to third countries. She pointed to the country’s reliance on imported vegetables and referred to Talamh Beo’s policy launch on basic income supports for local food producers as evidence of untapped potential.
Common Agricultural Policy funding
She contrasted the likely 24% reduction in CAP funding with more than €300 million in taxpayer spending connected to Ireland’s EU presidency. She said farmers were already struggling and questioned the EU Commission’s priorities if military spending increases while funding for food and agriculture is cut.
Consequences for rural communities
Newsome Drennan said farming should not be treated as just another business expense: when farms close, the consequences include empty shelves and a generational loss of knowledge. She also highlighted her claim that each euro of Common Agricultural Policy spending in Ireland generates €1.44 in economic output for the wider rural economy.

Political challenge on agriculture
She asked where the Irish Government’s voice had been in advocating for increased CAP funding and opposing cuts. Referring to other Fianna Fáil members’ confidence in the Minister for Agriculture securing a better deal, she said she did not share that confidence. Watch the recording to hear the full contribution.
We publish thousands of recordings to make Irish politics transparent and resistant to manipulation. Spotted an error? Report it — together we are building a reliable archive of Irish politics.
Other speeches
Natasha Newsome Drennan Questions Refrigerator Truck Meat Claims
Natasha Newsome Drennan: Inquiry must examine children's outcomes
Natasha Newsome Drennan demands answers on Skyclarys delay
Natasha Newsome Drennan: Nurses Deserve Action, Not Words
Natasha Newsome Drennan: Ministers Back Big Profits, Not People
Tego samego dnia All speeches from this day →
Brian Brennan
Brian Brennan challenges RTÉ on funding and value for money
Seán Crowe
Seán Crowe presses Minister on EU development aid
Robert O'Donoghue
Robert O'Donoghue asks how the EU can be made more accountable
Seán Kyne
Seán Kyne backs balanced rural short-term letting rules
Paraic Brady
Paraic Brady questions veterinary medicines sales and co-ops
Sharon Keogan
Sharon Keogan calls for Tusla to be abolished and rebuilt
Transcript
We are at a time of great uncertainty across the globe. The actions of the
United States are having a devastating impact on our economy. They continue to
pursue their policy of endless wars in Middle East and as a result ordinary
workers across Ireland and the EU are forced to pay the price. I have to ask
you, where is the strong leadership from the EU Commission to stand up to this
bully and say enough is enough? Other world leaders have shown leadership but
the EU along with Ireland continues to approach the United States cap in hand.
As I said we are in a deeply uncertain times. This is a time when we should be
increasing supports for domestic producers not increasing outsourcing of
food production to third countries beyond our control. Food security is
fundamental to a strong and secure state. At present we import 85% of our
gluten vegetables. Recently I was at the policy launch of Talam Beo basic income
for supports for local food producers and they show that like we have
enormous potential there. In the same year that the Irish taxpayer are
spending upwards of 300 million so that you can wine and dine EU officials for
the EU presidency our farmers and primary producers are being told that a
24% reduction in the cap looks likely. Minister our farmers are already
struggling and now the EU wants to drive that blade further in. Minister farming
in Ireland and across the EU cannot be viewed as just an expense or just an
order business because unlike order businesses when a farm ceases or goes
under it is not just layoffs it's empty shelves and a generational loss of
knowledge. I have to question how the EU Commission sets its priorities driving
up military spending while stripping the spend on food and agriculture. Minister
have a look at China a state three times the size of the EU in almost every
respect from population to landmass it spends far less than the EU on its
military budget. Rather than wasting endless money on weapons China is
driving forward investment in food production and food security and as
China has overtaken the EU on almost every front from research and innovation
to manufacturing maybe it is time that the EU stopped following the United
States in its blind policy of weaponizing stockpiling and started
looking at China's policies in investing in agriculture. Where has the Irish
government's voice been in advocating for an increased cap and in stopping the
stripping of cap to boost the military industry. Minister for every one
euro of common agriculture policy spending in Ireland it generates
1.44 euro cent of economic output back into the wider rural economy. This money
doesn't just stop at the farm gate the funds immediately circulate
through secondary rural businesses and unlike some other Fianna Ghael members
that said here today that they have faith in the Minister for Agriculture
that we will see a better deal. I don't have that same faith unfortunately.
you