Paul Murphy challenges Ireland’s Ukraine protection rules
Paul Murphy challenged the Irish Government over Ukraine-related temporary protection rules during a contribution to a Minister in the Oireachtas. He called for Ireland to opt out of rules requiring proof of military exemption and to count time spent under temporary protection towards naturalisation, while also urging questions about conscription practices during President Zelensky’s expected visit to Dublin.
Murphy called on the Minister to raise reports of forcible conscription and human rights abuses with President Zelensky during his expected visit to Dublin. He described people being taken to enlistment centres and alleged that wealthy people could avoid conscription by paying bribes, while working-class people were conscripted.
He said Ukrainians seeking refuge in Ireland could be sent back to fight if they lacked documents proving military exemption under the new temporary protection rules. Murphy argued that this risked returning refugees to a country where their lives could be threatened, contrary to the Refugee Convention.

Murphy urged Ireland to opt out of the rules, noting that Hungary had done so, and called for time spent in Ireland under temporary protection to count towards naturalisation.
Murphy called on the Minister to raise reports of forcible conscription and human rights abuses with President Zelensky during his expected visit to Dublin. He described people being taken to enlistment centres and alleged that wealthy people could avoid conscription by paying bribes, while working-class people were conscripted.
He said Ukrainians seeking refuge in Ireland could be sent back to fight if they lacked documents proving military exemption under the new temporary protection rules. Murphy argued that this risked returning refugees to a country where their lives could be threatened, contrary to the Refugee Convention.

We publish thousands of recordings to make Irish politics transparent and resistant to manipulation. Spotted an error? Report it — together we are building a reliable archive of Irish politics.
Other speeches
Paul Murphy: Demands Action Over Tara Mines Closure
Paul Murphy challenges Chair's constitutional ruling
Paul Murphy: Calls to Criminalise Wage Theft, Urges Specialist Unit
Paul Murphy Slams Cuts to Ukrainian Refugee Support Payments
Paul Murphy: Demands 400 Classes to End Exclusion of Disabled Children
Paul Murphy: Calls Out Government Climate Contradiction
Tego samego dnia All speeches from this day →
Alan Kelly
Alan Kelly challenges RTÉ funding handling and podcast appointment
Carol Nolan
Carol Nolan Questions Short-Term Letting Bill’s Rural Impact
Richard Boyd Barrett
Richard Boyd Barrett: Housing for people, not profit
Michael Fitzmaurice
Michael Fitzmaurice questions fairness in farm supply chains
George Lawlor
George Lawlor: Short-term let rules must be targeted
Michael Fitzmaurice
Michael Fitzmaurice presses for VetPal viability analysis
Transcript
Minister, it's incredibly almost five years since Putin invaded Ukraine.
The death toll is utterly horrifying, running into the hundreds of thousands of people.
But we can't close our eyes to the abuses of human rights that are taking place in Ukraine.
The government shouldn't continue to close its eyes.
When President Zelensky is here in Dublin in a couple of weeks' time, you need to ask
him about the policies of internment, of forcible conscription into the Ukrainian army that
are now, that have been rolled out across Ukraine.
People are being taken off the streets in unmarked vans to enlistment centres if they
can't produce the right exemption documents in a policy known as busification.
Those conscripted have been reported to be injured by the officers enforcing this practice.
One man, Andriy Drobrovsky, a 26-year-old man, reported having his leg broken during detainment.
And this is conscription for the working class, for ordinary people, it's not for the rich.
Because the rich can bribe their way out of conscription.
We can't ignore this.
You need to call out the abuses of human rights.
The other thing, though, is you need to not be complicit in these abuses of human rights.
Because right now, Ukrainians are suffering under the new temporary protection rules,
which require proof of military exemption in order to be able to get temporary protection
elsewhere in the European Union.
Ukrainians who don't have it are forced back into a war that they don't support, that they
don't want to be fighting in.
The Irish government is currently complicit by sending people who have come here seeking
refuge, saying we don't want to fight, if they don't have the military exemption documents,
they are sent back by the Irish government to fight.
It flies in the face of the Convention relating to the status of refugees, which says that
refugees cannot be returned to a country in which they are likely to face a threat to
their life.
Minister, Hungary has opted out of these new rules.
The Irish government should as well.
We should also be counting the years Ukrainians have been here under temporary protection
towards naturalisation.
There's no reason for these people to be denied citizenship while under this protection.
For more UN videos visit www.un.org