Matt Carthy says Horkan family deserve answers
Sinn Féin TD Matt Carthy called for an independent public inquiry into the circumstances leading up to Garda Colm Horkan’s death during a Dáil debate on Garda whistleblowing and protected disclosures. He argued that the Horkan family, Garda whistleblowers and the public need answers about warnings over Garda equipment and how those concerns were handled.
Carthy said Sinn Féin had consistently called for transparency, accountability and independent scrutiny of serious issues raised by Garda whistleblowers. He argued that confidence in the protected disclosures regime within An Garda Síochána had largely collapsed and that the Horkan family’s request for a public inquiry into the circumstances leading to Garda Colm Horkan’s death should be taken seriously.
He questioned whether referring the matter to Fiosrú would provide answers, citing the delay in the public interest inquiry into the death of Shane O’Farrell and the family’s ongoing efforts to access it. He said the Horkan family had raised questions about Garda holsters, the handling of complaints and protected disclosures, and the response of Garda management and relevant authorities to concerns raised in advance.
Carthy also called for answers about the procurement of the holsters, how safety concerns were handled, and the treatment of those who made protected disclosures. He said the disclosures concerned public safety, Garda equipment, firearm storage, procurement and oversight, and asked whether lessons from the treatment of Maurice McCabe had been learned.

He called on former Justice Minister Helen McEntee to answer questions in the Dáil about what she knew, when she knew it, how disclosures were handled and what steps were taken to protect whistleblowers. He said the public, members of An Garda Síochána and the Horkan family deserved answers.
Carthy said Sinn Féin had consistently called for transparency, accountability and independent scrutiny of serious issues raised by Garda whistleblowers. He argued that confidence in the protected disclosures regime within An Garda Síochána had largely collapsed and that the Horkan family’s request for a public inquiry into the circumstances leading to Garda Colm Horkan’s death should be taken seriously.
He questioned whether referring the matter to Fiosrú would provide answers, citing the delay in the public interest inquiry into the death of Shane O’Farrell and the family’s ongoing efforts to access it. He said the Horkan family had raised questions about Garda holsters, the handling of complaints and protected disclosures, and the response of Garda management and relevant authorities to concerns raised in advance.
Carthy also called for answers about the procurement of the holsters, how safety concerns were handled, and the treatment of those who made protected disclosures. He said the disclosures concerned public safety, Garda equipment, firearm storage, procurement and oversight, and asked whether lessons from the treatment of Maurice McCabe had been learned.

We publish thousands of recordings to make Irish politics transparent and resistant to manipulation. Spotted an error? Report it — together we are building a reliable archive of Irish politics.
Other speeches
Matt Carthy: Government Failing Children on Dental Care
Matt Carthy: Childcare crisis is a government failure
Matt Carthy demands Dáil debate on EU migration pact
Matt Carthy to Vote No Confidence Tonight
Matt Carthy: Minister O'Callaghan's EU Opt-In Rubber Stamp
Matt Carthy demands clarity on looming student fee rise
Tego samego dnia All speeches from this day →
Barry Ward
Barry Ward presses for EU blocking statute on US sanctions
Peter Burke
Peter Burke sets out national short-term letting register
Richard Boyd Barrett
Richard Boyd Barrett: Housing for people, not profit
Thomas Gould
Thomas Gould: Cork Prison History and Traffic Gridlock
Victor Boyhan
Victor Boyhan: Keep horticulture in focus in Food Vision 2030
Danny Healy-Rae
Danny Healy-Rae warns Airbnb rules could hurt rural Kerry
Transcript
Matt Carroll, 7.5.
Go raibh maith agat, ceo híor leac agus tácíon Sinn Féin leis an tóra seo, agus fáilteam
ribh an deas learth fíon na ceisne seo in iú.
Sinn Féin has consistently called for transparency, accountability and independent scrutiny when
serious issues raised by Garda Whistleblowers come before us, as well as the need to have
accountability with regard to the overall effectiveness of the protected disclosures
mechanisms within An Garda Síochána.
It has to be said, Minister, and you need to recognise that there is virtually no confidence
now that the protected disclosure regime within An Garda Síochána is functioning, and that
has serious, serious implications.
I obviously want to join others in paying tribute to Colm Horkam, but I think we need
to be incredibly mindful in this House that the Horkam family have taken a significant
and, I would suggest, unprecedented step for the family of Garda, killed in action,
to call for a public inquiry into the circumstances leading up to his death.
That has to be taken seriously, and that's why it's so disappointing to see your amendment
here today, Minister, which essentially boils down to rejecting that call.
I want to also join the Minister in this regard and other members in saying that Stephen Silver
is the person who was responsible for Colm Horkam's death.
He was rightly convicted, but his family are also entitled to know whether the tragedy
could have been prevented, whether concerns that were raised in advance through protected
disclosure regarding Garda equipment were properly acted upon.
And the family have set out a series of specific questions and made them public regarding the
enjoyment of gun holsters, the handling of complaints and protected disclosures, and
the actions taken by Garda management and the relevant authorities when concerns were
first raised.
They have said, and I actually agree with them, that the questions can only be properly
examined through an independent inquiry.
Minister, I am a little bit taken aback that you have passed this on to FISRA and have
told this House that that is the forum that is going to resolve this issue.
You know, and we have heard countless evidence, that GSOC throughout its existence was seen
not as an avenue for families to get truth or the public to get answers, but actually
as a delaying model.
And you know that, for example, a case that we are both well aware of, the case of Shane
O'Farrell, that a successor to yours in 2014 asked then GSOC to carry out a public interest
inquiry, the exact same type of inquiry that your suggestion will warrant in this case.
You will know that that inquiry completed in 2018 and you will know that today, in 2026,
the family of Shane O'Farrell are actually before the courts trying to get access to
that public interest inquiry.
And you know that the Oireachtas Committee on Justice, the committee that has the responsibility
for this, has actually sought of FISRA that public interest inquiry and they are refusing
to provide it even to an Oireachtas committee.
So to suggest that FISRA is a vehicle that will get answers is entirely disingenuous
when all of the evidence suggests that in fact it is a delaying tactic and a tactic
that will frustrate rather than facilitate the route to answers.
There are serious, serious questions that have been raised here today and elsewhere
regarding the procurement of the holsters and whether and how one particular saddlery
received the contract when we need to know and the public need to know whether procurement
decisions were based on appropriate and objective assessment criteria.
There's a key question regarding the handling of the safety concerns relating to the holsters
and whether the warnings that were raised through the protected disclosures system were
properly acted upon.
These are questions that need to be answered.
We also need answers to the questions in respect of those who made protected disclosures.
How were they treated?
Were in fact the lessons that we were told were learned after the treatment of Maurice
McCabe, were they actually learned and what is the current situation?
Because we're told that those who made protected disclosures have faced serious consequences
impacting on their jobs, careers, their livelihoods.
And the issues that they have raised, they relate to public safety, they relate to the
safety of members of An Garda Síochána, they relate to Garda equipment, to firearm
storage, to procurement practices and oversight.
In other words, Minister, they are very, very serious, serious issues and the state promised
that whistleblowers would never again experience the treatment that was suffered by Maurice
McCabe.
And the question we have to ask is whether or not in fact things have changed and there
are serious, and I want to say this, there are serious questions remaining regarding
former Justice Minister Helen McEntee's handling of protected disclosure and her role
in all of this debacle.
This House needs and deserves answers as to what the Minister knew when she knew it, what
disclosures were brought to her attention, what actions she took, why were concerns involving
senior Garda figures actually handed back to the Gardaí, what her role was in terms
of upholding the independence of the protected disclosures process and what measures, if
any, she took to actually protect the disclosure.
She has to come before this House and answer questions.
We had the laughable situation yesterday of the tarnished Simon Harris saying that a member
should come before this House and make a statement in respect of their role in a charity.
And that member has requested time to do that and at the same time he is standing in front
of a current Minister of the Cabinet actually coming in here despite repeated requests and
answering questions in respect to the safety of members of An Garda Síochána and what
she did when information was brought to her attention.
That position is untenable and the fact, Minister, that you have essentially told me in the Dáil
that you would do what she did if the situation were to occur again points to me that far
from lessons having been learned, we are back to square one and we have a serious fundamental
issue in our public system and particularly in terms of An Garda Síochána when people
at huge cost to themselves decide to make a protected disclosure and the role of protected
disclosures is to inform management, to inform government, to inform the public that there
are potential risks within a system.
They did that, they deserve to be commended for doing that and we then collectively have
an obligation to act upon it.
So there cannot be any more hiding, there cannot be hiding for Minister McEntee and
her role, she has to come before the House, she has to answer the questions that are before
us because above all the public need answers, the members of the Garda Síochána need answers,
the Horkan family deserve answers because we're six years on, questions have been raised
on multiple occasions in this House, they deserve to be answered and Minister you cannot
hide behind Físirú or anyone else, you have a responsibility to ensure that those questions
are actually answered.