Richard Boyd Barrett challenges Donnybrook housing mix
Richard Boyd Barrett questioned a company representative about the planned tenure mix at the former RTÉ site in Donnybrook during a discussion of housing figures. He challenged the prospect that around 600 homes would be built mainly for the private market, with no affordable apartments confirmed at this stage, on what had been a public site.
Boyd Barrett asked the company representative whether the Donnybrook development would include affordable homes and how many units were planned. The representative said the scheme was designed for the private market alongside social apartments, that affordable homes might be included, and that about 600 units were likely overall, with none currently confirmed as affordable.
Boyd Barrett argued that a former public site should not be used mainly for homes beyond the means of working people, particularly in an area with high house prices. He asked what prices the homes might reach and whether there was a reason for a lower proportion of social and affordable housing there than in other parts of Dublin 4.

The representative declined to provide further information on prices, citing the focus of the discussion on housing figures. The representative said the company took affordability seriously, gave an average sale price of about €380,000 across its portfolio, and pointed to a cost-rental and affordable development in Shankill delivered for Tuath Housing.
Boyd Barrett asked the company representative whether the Donnybrook development would include affordable homes and how many units were planned. The representative said the scheme was designed for the private market alongside social apartments, that affordable homes might be included, and that about 600 units were likely overall, with none currently confirmed as affordable.
Boyd Barrett argued that a former public site should not be used mainly for homes beyond the means of working people, particularly in an area with high house prices. He asked what prices the homes might reach and whether there was a reason for a lower proportion of social and affordable housing there than in other parts of Dublin 4.

We publish thousands of recordings to make Irish politics transparent and resistant to manipulation. Spotted an error? Report it — together we are building a reliable archive of Irish politics.
Other speeches
Richard Boyd Barrett: Urges State Action on Childcare Insurance Crisis
Richard Boyd Barrett blasts Garda refusal on Dublin Monaghan files
Richard Boyd Barrett: Questions IDA, Enterprise Ireland Role in Arms
Richard Boyd Barrett: Is the EU Complicit in Gaza Atrocities?
Richard Boyd Barrett Demands Advisory Minutes, Slams CPL Contracts
Richard Boyd Barrett: Will Government Adopt Parents' SNA Circular?
Tego samego dnia All speeches from this day →
Paul Nicholas Gogarty
Paul Nicholas Gogarty calls for rural Ireland to be repopulated
Micheál Martin
Micheál Martin sets out record infrastructure investment
Rose Conway-Walsh
Rose Conway-Walsh challenges legacy Bill's human rights test
Victor Boyhan
Victor Boyhan challenges Minister over A&E crisis
Sharon Keogan
Sharon Keogan presses for Navan-Drogheda rail reopening
Carol Nolan
Carol Nolan says Midlands left out of transition plan
Transcript
Can I ask about the site in Donnybrook, the RTE site, what's the tenure mix there?
Tenure mix there is, will be private, it will be for private self, private individual owners
and obviously will have its part five social apartments in it as well.
So is it any affordable?
Not in that scheme, no, not directly affordable, no.
So on what was used to be, and this is not your, well you have some influence obviously,
so what used to be a public site will get 10% social and that's it?
And no affordable?
Well I wouldn't rule out affordable at this point in time and I have to say that we are
obviously as a PLC there's certain information that's available publicly and certain information
that I can't expand too much on.
But there is a possibility that RTE may include, or Montrose as we call it, may include some
affordable apartments but at this point in time it has been designed for the private
market and will also have some social apartments in it.
It may have affordable but we only are building the first phase of that development.
Just remind us, how many units being built there altogether?
Likely to be about 600 units.
600 units and currently, just so we're clear, currently none of them affordable?
Not at this point in time, no.
On what used to be a public site?
I don't suppose you'd tell us how much you paid for it, would you?
That's publicly available information.
Well then tell us, just as a matter of interest.
But if you don't mind, let me clarify, if you don't mind Deputy, we have a business
where we have to provide and do provide mixed tenure developments throughout Ireland.
We build in major cities like Cork, Galway, Limerick and Dublin.
I could equally count at least a dozen sites that we are on that are exclusively social affordable.
Sure, okay, Michael.
So we build a portfolio.
Thanks for that information but see I'm particularly concerned as I pass it most days, right, and
I personally, and it's not entirely your fault, but I just think the public deserve to know
what used to be a public site is now going to be 90% for the market in Dublin 4 where
probably we've got the highest house prices in the country.
So they're going to be distinctly unaffordable for working people.
Would you have any rough idea of what sort of prices they're going to be going for?
I wouldn't at this stage provide any more information on that development.
I think it would be fair to say they're going to be well north of, you know, the average
house price in the country.
Would that be a reasonable assumption?
I think we're straying a little bit away from the course of the discussion today, which
is the housing figures.
Can I ask just about, well, yeah, I'm just interested in, it is related to, you know,
what we get at the end of all of this because there's statistics and there's figures, but
if nobody can afford them, well, how much they contribute to solving the crisis, which
is what we're really concerned about, let's be honest, right?
Isn't it?
I mean, the reason there's a problem with discrepancies is because how it relates to
solving the problem that we have, right?
And the problem is there's a housing crisis in this country.
And as a company, Deputy, we take that affordability challenge very seriously.
We wouldn't be selling 2,700 homes, 700 homes a year if we did not offer competitively priced
homes.
But would it be fair to say, Michael, that it contributes?
If you don't mind, I'll finish the point.
Yeah.
The average caring home over the last five years, the average selling price for our homes
has not moved by any more than 4,000 or 5,000 euros a year.
So, we are selling homes on average across our portfolio at about 380,000 euros.
Sure.
That's our average.
And that would include homes at the higher price points and homes at the lower price
So, this is in the adjoining constituency, and it's just over, right?
But what I'm concerned about is, see, if you're a council worker or an ambulance driver or
somebody who works in a shop, you don't earn more because you live in Dublin 4 or in Dun
Laoghaire-Rathdown, right?
You don't get higher wages.
But you have to deal with the consequences of house prices being much higher and rents
being much higher.
And to my mind, you know, unless we're contributing to doing something about that in every area,
we're exacerbating the housing prices in those areas.
You'd probably be aware of our Shangana development then, which is in the same location, which
delivered 190,000 cost rental and crowd apartments, beautifully delivered in Shangana, run now
by Tua Housing, exclusively social affordable.
So, we'll continue.
You heard that 40% of them didn't meet standards, did you?
Sorry?
40% of the cost rental in Shankill.
This was discussed at the council in Shangana Castle.
Shangana Castle may be a different development.
Sorry, not Shangana Castle.
No.
Excuse me.
Shankill.
Yeah.
It was our own direct delivery.
Not on behalf.
That was not.
Shangana Castle, as I understand it, was a Dun Laoghaire-Rathdown delivery.
This was a privately delivered apartment development, which we did on behalf of Tua Housing.
My point is, we take all tenures seriously.
We provide homes across multiple tenures, and we wouldn't be a successful business unless
we did that.
And we wouldn't be a successful growing business unless we provided value for money for our
Yeah.
I was just asking, is there a reason that there would be a much lower proportion of
affordable and social, indeed, than there are in some areas in Dublin 4?
On a site like that, then there might be in other areas.
Is there a reason for that?
To me, I can't think of a good reason.
30 seconds.
I just want to move on to the next speaker.
I think I've responded to that.
Send her over.