Jennifer Whitmore warns Ireland imports 83% of fruit and vegetables
Jennifer Whitmore told a Minister that Ireland imports 83% of its fruit and vegetables during a contribution on rural communities and agriculture. She called for reform of the agricultural sector, arguing that Ireland’s reliance on imported produce leaves its food supply less secure and resilient.
She said rural Ireland had changed significantly, with intensification in agriculture over the past 20 to 30 years creating problems for communities that needed to remain vibrant, strong and resilient. She argued that the development of the sector should be reconsidered.
Whitmore said Ireland had 600 fruit and vegetable producers in the 1990s, compared with 70 at the time of her contribution. She said that if food supply routes were shut down, the country would be left relying on beef and dairy, despite its strong food-security ranking.

She called for work to reform agriculture in response to climate change and global instability. She asked the Minister to take part in that work and raise the issue with colleagues.
She said rural Ireland had changed significantly, with intensification in agriculture over the past 20 to 30 years creating problems for communities that needed to remain vibrant, strong and resilient. She argued that the development of the sector should be reconsidered.
Whitmore said Ireland had 600 fruit and vegetable producers in the 1990s, compared with 70 at the time of her contribution. She said that if food supply routes were shut down, the country would be left relying on beef and dairy, despite its strong food-security ranking.

We publish thousands of recordings to make Irish politics transparent and resistant to manipulation. Spotted an error? Report it — together we are building a reliable archive of Irish politics.
Other speeches
Jennifer Whitmore calls for energy windfall tax and €400 credit
Jennifer Whitmore: Legislate Now for Women Forced to Travel
Jennifer Whitmore: Demands Transparency on LNG Facility Bill
Jennifer Whitmore: Women need endometriosis care here
Jennifer Whitmore: Energy Crisis Is a Social Justice Crisis
Jennifer Whitmore Demands Windfall Tax on Energy Profits
Tego samego dnia All speeches from this day →
Mary Lou McDonald
Mary Lou McDonald challenges Taoiseach on public service pay
Richard Boyd Barrett
Richard Boyd Barrett Questions LDA Over Shanganagh Homes
Brian Stanley
Brian Stanley: Hospitals lack capacity as trolley numbers soar
Sharon Keogan
Sharon Keogan presses for Navan-Drogheda rail reopening
Victor Boyhan
Victor Boyhan salutes Philomena Lee and Philomena’s Law
Carol Nolan
Carol Nolan warns trolley numbers mask wider health capacity gaps
Transcript
Minister, I think Ireland is probably quite unusual in that no matter where
you're born, whether you could be born in the middle of the city or in a large
town, you're only a generation or two from rural Ireland and I think
you know many of us would have those family connections or community
connections if we're not living in rural Ireland ourselves. I think the
face of rural Ireland has changed quite significantly over the last number of
years. I think in some ways there's been positive change as there has been
across the entire country. I think in some ways that has been quite regressive.
My colleague mentioned sustainable agriculture there and the intensification
of agriculture that we have seen over the last 20 or 30 years in Ireland and I
think it is usually problematic for those communities that you're
trying to make vibrant and strong and resilient. I think in order to do that I
do think there needs to be a relook at agriculture and how agriculture has
developed over and has been really forced into developing into a more
intensified area than I think is really positive for the
communities. I think Minister if you go to any, you could go into any supermarket
in this country and the first thing if you're looking for vegetables or fruit
the first thing you'll notice is that most of it is coming from overseas. It's
coming from the UK, there's apples from Fiji, apples from New Zealand and I
think when you look around those sections in the supermarket it is just
such a pure illustration of how agriculture in Ireland, how broken it is
and how much we need to do in order to make it more secure and more resilient
and better able to meet the needs of the communities that survive on agriculture
and farmers within those communities. We import 83% of our fruit and vegetables
many of which we could and used to produce here in this country and whilst
we hear all the time how food secure Ireland is, I think we're you know in the
top one or two percent of food security countries in the world, that's a really
lazy narrative because it doesn't actually show what it
pretends to show. In actual fact if our food supply lanes were shut down in the
morning we would be surviving on beef and dairy and that's the reality and
whilst there are positives obviously we've you know there's a huge economy in
exporting beef and dairy but I think what we have done and what previous
governments have done is actually turned its back from the more
traditional sectors like the fruit and veg sector. We in the 1990s had 600
producers, we're now down to 70 and Minister what I would say to you in these
last few seconds is there is the alarm bells ringing about how food insecure we
are. There is a huge piece of work to do to look at our farm, our agricultural
sector and reform it in light of not just climate change but the global
instability that we are seeing. We are not doing that work and I would ask that
you participate in that and go home and raise it with your colleagues. Thank you.