Menu
VideoParliament
VideoParliament Irish politics in one place — download the app
Get app
VideoParliament
VideoParliament for Windows Get the desktop app — notifications about new speeches
Get app
George Lawlor asks how AI will protect workers’ rights

George Lawlor asks how AI will protect workers’ rights

At a committee hearing, George Lawlor raised concerns about workers’ rights as artificial intelligence reshapes workplaces and asked witnesses about an AI agreement with Bank of Ireland. He also asked how a stakeholder forum could bring workers, businesses and other groups into decisions about workplace AI.

Lawlor said the pace and scale of AI-driven change called for a revised approach to workplace change agreements, with safeguards around matters such as human oversight, transparency and surveillance. He said the principles underpinning the Bank of Ireland agreement originated in European social dialogue on banking and were brought to the bank as a basis for agreement.

A witness explained that the agreement built on existing change and technology agreements with Bank of Ireland. It reflected workers’ interest in safeguards and the principle that humans remain in control, while allowing for change and giving workers influence over how it is introduced.

George Lawlor — still from speech: George Lawlor asks how AI will protect workers’ rights (20.10.2026)
In response to Lawlor’s question about a stakeholder forum, a witness proposed bringing together workers, employers, government, consumer groups, NGOs and other relevant stakeholders to discuss AI in the workplace. The witness said the department responsible for AI should convene such a forum, and argued that workplace integration of AI should be managed collectively, collaboratively and transparently.

We publish thousands of recordings to make Irish politics transparent and resistant to manipulation. Spotted an error? Report it — together we are building a reliable archive of Irish politics.

Tego samego dnia All speeches from this day →

Transcript
Thank you, and I'd like to thank the witnesses for their presentations today. I suppose we often hear the term something is barrelling down the tracks at us, but this is well and truly driven over us and we're in many respects playing catch up. I come from a printing background, and I'm old enough to remember the days of whopping and the introduction of new technologies, and one of the things that certainly wasn't front and centre were workers' rights in that whole area, and de-skilling and down-skilling were front and centre of a lot that went on at that time, and I can re-see this happening in the whole area of AI, and the benefits will, I think we can be guaranteed, will not be wholly, as we know, destined to workers. There's no doubt AI has huge benefits, particularly in the area of health and stuff like that, and we will obviously acknowledge that. I have a couple of questions. In relation to John, I'd be interested to hear about the agreement you have with Bank of Ireland. I think that's something that obviously is the first, as you stated. I'd be interested to know more, if you could flesh that out, and how it came about, how it's working, your interaction with the company, and what I'm hearing also from talks is that we really do need a stakeholders forum on this, and on AI, and how would that look, and who, I suppose, should organise it, those are my two questions. So, in relation to the Bank of Ireland agreement, we have existing change agreements with the bank, and indeed we have existing technology change agreements with the bank. I suppose the difference with AI is what Ian referred to, both the pace and scale of the change is such that it requires, I suppose, a revised approach, and other things have developed over the years, particularly around surveillance and issues like that, and people want to have safeguards, they understand that we're in a change environment and that, but they want safeguards around that, so we engaged with our members and reflected that to the bank. I should also say that the origin to the agreement started in Europe, where I sit in social dialogue on the banking forum in Europe, and they agreed a set of principles, and it was the principles we brought to Bank of Ireland and said, these are a set of principles agreed by your representative bodies in Europe, we believe they give the basis for us to reach agreement with you around how change and AI interacts in Bank of Ireland. So, as I said, it addresses some things that are normal in change agreements, but issues like human oversight and issues like transparency and surveillance are issues that are new, are relatively new in the workplace in the form that they come to us with AI. And I think from our point of view, we were looking as well around the human in control principle because that's, I suppose, really, really important, and again, wouldn't have been something we envisaged a number of years ago when we were bringing normal change agreements through the organisations. So that's the Bank of Ireland, and I think it's a template in terms of change and how change can come about, where, as everybody has said on the trade union side here today, we're not opposed to the change, it's how the change comes about and what influence we can shape that change and our entitlement to shape that change, so I think that's one part of it. And then in relation to the stakeholder forum, do you want to talk to that, Bernie? Yeah, thank you, Deputy, for the question. We were here, I think, two to three years ago in the Finance Committee looking for a banking forum which would bring together stakeholders throughout the ecosystem in banking, bring them together to see how we could manage the change that was coming in the financial system. And a huge success, report done by the Department of Finance, 34 different recommendations, access to cash legislation, for example, one of those things, one of those items, that was agreed through that banking forum. It brought together consumer groups, NGOs, trade unions, employers, government, and every stakeholder, every relevant stakeholder, and it's our firm view that we should do something similar here, because it's going to have such a serious effect on the workplace. We have met with Minister Smith, who is responsible for AI, we have asked her would she consider it, it's our view that her department should be the ones that calls those stakeholders together, because at the end of the day, again, and I'm repeating what others have said, we're not against the integration of AI into the workplace, but it's how that's managed. It has to be done collectively, it has to be done collaboratively, but for the workers it has to be done transparently. And getting relevant stakeholders in a room is a good way to start. And if it's done properly, it's good for workers, it's good for business, it's good for consumers. So let's have them all in a room together and talking about it and discussing it. Thanks, Brian. Thanks, Deputy. Thank you.