Mattie McGrath challenges South Tipperary water response
Mattie McGrath challenged the handling of a Do Not Consume Notice affecting more than 11,000 South Tipperary customers during an Oireachtas exchange on water safety. He questioned why the public was informed five days after aluminium levels were recorded above EU limits and pressed the Minister for Health on transparency and accountability.
McGrath said aluminium levels had exceeded EU limits during the previous month and cited levels recorded on 4 October, five days before the notice was issued. He argued that communities and elected representatives had not been given the full picture, damaging trust in public water supplies.
He highlighted continuing boil water notices in South Tipperary, including in Tipperary Town since the previous February. McGrath described the effects on families, schools, childcare providers, farmers and businesses, and said some residents had not heard about the water warning and were still drinking the water.
McGrath challenged the lack of accountability for water operations and asked the Minister to support legislation that would make the relevant body answerable to parliamentary questions. He also criticised the absence of information from the HSE and EPA, saying people had resorted to Freedom of Information requests to obtain answers.

The Minister said the Do Not Consume Notice for the Ardfinnan Regional Water Supply Scheme had been lifted on 19 October after works, flushing and water-quality testing. However, the boil water notice remained in place pending further testing and monitoring, with alternative water supplies to continue for vulnerable customers. Watch the recording to hear the full exchange.
Delayed public warning
McGrath said aluminium levels had exceeded EU limits during the previous month and cited levels recorded on 4 October, five days before the notice was issued. He argued that communities and elected representatives had not been given the full picture, damaging trust in public water supplies.
Ongoing boil water notices
He highlighted continuing boil water notices in South Tipperary, including in Tipperary Town since the previous February. McGrath described the effects on families, schools, childcare providers, farmers and businesses, and said some residents had not heard about the water warning and were still drinking the water.
Questions over accountability
McGrath challenged the lack of accountability for water operations and asked the Minister to support legislation that would make the relevant body answerable to parliamentary questions. He also criticised the absence of information from the HSE and EPA, saying people had resorted to Freedom of Information requests to obtain answers.

Minister’s response
The Minister said the Do Not Consume Notice for the Ardfinnan Regional Water Supply Scheme had been lifted on 19 October after works, flushing and water-quality testing. However, the boil water notice remained in place pending further testing and monitoring, with alternative water supplies to continue for vulnerable customers. Watch the recording to hear the full exchange.
We publish thousands of recordings to make Irish politics transparent and resistant to manipulation. Spotted an error? Report it — together we are building a reliable archive of Irish politics.
Other speeches
Mattie McGrath: Demands Government Make Banks 'Play Their Part'
Mattie McGrath warns amendments risk unclear implementation for clubs
Mattie McGrath warns insurance crisis threatens communities
Mattie McGrath: Blames Government for Housing and Asylum Crisis
Mattie McGrath: Condemns lone patrols after guard almost killed
Mattie McGrath backs emergency powers to protect public health
Tego samego dnia All speeches from this day →
Barry Andrews
Barry Andrews: AI needs global governance
Albert Dolan
Albert Dolan presses for hot school meals fix in Moyglass
Jennifer Whitmore
Jennifer Whitmore: Women need endometriosis care here
Gerard P. Craughwell
Gerard P. Craughwell questions Defence Forces grievance pathways
Pearse Doherty
Pearse Doherty challenges Minister over elderly patients waiting
Sharon Keogan
Sharon Keogan criticises consent campaign on family greetings
Transcript
Last Friday evening, the 9th of October, 7.30pm, HGN issued a Consume Notice to over 11,000
customers in South Tipperary.
The impression was given that there had been a failure at the Golden Ritz plant and that
that day an aluminium levels were too high and this urgent action had been taken.
Chaos ensued over the following days and I want to thank the HGN staff on the ground
who helped out with the water.
Following days, families, businesses, schools, childcare providers, farmers and vulnerable
people were left scrambling for information.
What happened however was that this was not an urgent decision taken on an extreme measure
on a Friday evening but aluminium levels had in fact exceeded the EU levels for most of
the previous month.
Indeed, on October 4th, five days before the Do Not Consume Notice was introduced, aluminium
levels on our water were in excess of 2,300 mg per litre, almost 12 times the EU levels
of 200 mg per litre, and two and a half times the much higher World Health Organisation
levels.
Yet HGN waited five days to inform the public that water was not safe to consume.
What is most concerning is that communities were not given the full picture of the truth.
Elected representatives were kept in the dark and the truth only emerged when people we
put down a piece of information, and that's not acceptable.
Naturally, trust in the safety of public water is severely damaged and it's going to take
a long time to be regained.
The public on this line have already been on a Bile Water Notice all summer, the driest
summer we've ever got, and they are on Tipperary Town, the whole of Tipperary Town is on a
Bile Water Notice since last February.
Shocking state of affairs in South Tipperary.
But the Do Not Consume, which HGN said then on Friday that the critical upgrade was completed
last Friday.
And how can it be?
We're still on a Bile Water Notice, we can't drink the water on the taps, and in my honour
I've lived in that area as well, how can the critical upgrades be completed?
We still can't drink the water, as I said.
This raises fundamental questions about transparency and accountability, a lack of, with HGN.
When members put down a PQ here to Ministers, you're told you have no responsibility.
Fine Gael, your government, Phil Hogan, set up HGN, so it's time, there's change now,
do we have accountability in the South, because there's accountability with nobody.
Do you accept that we cannot allow a situation where HGN are completely on account of operational
matters, and can you commit to supporting private members, as I have, and bringing legislation
yourself to make Parliament answerable to Parliamentary questions.
We can't have this cabal doing what they're doing, the CEO we see is getting 7,500 a week,
he approved over 100,000 increase from recently.
So it's just shocking, it begs us to believe that this is going on, shocking, it begs us
to believe that this is going on.
There's no accountability whatsoever, as I said, and the public need full disclosure
of all, at all times, about safety, and Minister for Health, you're the Minister for Health,
we haven't had a peep from the HSE or the EPA, they're all the time telling us that
they're watching, monitoring and doing things in conjunction with Irish Water.
We've asked questions to them, and we have had to go to FOI as well to get answers.
This is scandalous, I'm glad you're here to take this as Minister for Health, it's
a serious, critical health issue for all people, especially for young babies.
Thank you Deputy, the Do Not Consume Notice for customers on the Ardfanan Regional Water
Supply Scheme was lifted on Monday 19th October, following consultation with the HSE, and the
lifting of the Do Not Consume Notice followed the completion of critical works at Goughton
Bridge Water Treatment Plant, which an extensive targeting flushing programme across the network
and comprehensive water quality sampling at both the plant and across the regional network
over the weekend. However, customers, as you're aware, and as you've highlighted, must continue
to boil water before drinking, before preparing food and drinks, before brushing teeth or
making ice, as the boil water notice remains in place. And the focus in Aoisge Arran is
now getting to a point where that boil water notice can be lifted as quickly and as safely
as possible. The completion of the works at Goughton Bridge Water Treatment Plant is a
important step in that. There will be further testing and monitoring to continue to provide
the evidence required. That will be done in consultation with the HSE, who you correctly
identify as being a key partner in that, and that's what's important in relation to determining
when the boil water notice can safely be lifted. As you correctly identify, it impacts so very
many different people, but particularly more vulnerable people, and thank you for raising it.
Sir, I'm very disappointed with your reply, because as Minister for Health you must be
at 69 and more above the safe limit, and yet we weren't told for a month,
and the public wasn't informed. There's absolutely no accountability, none whatsoever.
You said again, you read out there that critical works had been completed,
and we're still on a boil water notice. So that's not fit for purpose. If we can't drink the water
and the critical upgrade is completed, we're in an awful situation. Tipperary town is on a boil
water notice since last February. No information as to when it's going to be taken off it.
Many parts of South Tipperary, I think there was about 50,000 customers at Pineshield in the summer
had no water for days and weeks on end. How are businesses supposed to operate? And the farmers,
they got no information at all about this, and but for social media and my own did,
Councillor Maury McGrath and others that told the people about this, many people didn't know
about this for days, because they're not on social media, and they didn't use the civil
defence or anything else like they used to, to leave their houses, to tell them,
so they're drinking the water. On Tuesday, I was visiting, or the following week, I was visiting
the site of the strikes, the people on strike, and I got a call from a family that they had
known anything about the water, and they were still drinking it. Would I drop water for them?
And I did. And I thanked, as I said, the HQN staff on the ground for the help, and the security as
well, and the companies that deliver the water. But this is fundamentally not working, Irish water.
Thank you, Deputy. And obviously, knowledge of the difficulty is very important, and I'd highlight
the role of local radio, in particular in Tip FM, who provide a very, very important service
to constituents, including being able to highlight issues of this significance. Of course, the
boil water notice continues until the issue has been addressed, but if you'll pardon the pun,
it still has to flush out through the system to make sure that the system is all clear now,
and that ongoing testing is necessary. So it's not an immediate solution. There is a boil water
notice following the do not consume notice. Iska Aran's upgrade programme at the plant is
nearing completion. They are committed to improving reliability and resilience of the
Ardfanan regional water supply. It does require a sustained investment to strengthen the overall
water supply. Throughout the notice, tankers, boiled water and bulk water supplies have been
made available to try to support communities across the affected area, which is important.
Again, alternative water supplies will continue to be provided to more vulnerable customers
while the boil water notice remains in place. Thank you.