Brian Stanley: Triple Lock abolition is not reform
Sinn Féin TD Brian Stanley criticised the Government’s Defence Bill during an Oireachtas debate, arguing that it would abolish the Triple Lock and change Ireland’s approach to neutrality and the United Nations. He said changing the arrangements without a referendum would deny Irish citizens a say on a matter he believes they endorsed through the Lisbon and Nice treaty declarations.
Stanley said the Bill was not a minor adjustment to defence and foreign policy, but a major change to Ireland’s position on international relations and the UN. He challenged the Government’s description of the proposals as reform of the Triple Lock, saying: “it's not reform of the Triple Lock, it's abolition of it.”
Stanley disputed claims that Ireland could not deploy more than 12 troops for rescue missions without UN Security Council approval. He said the legislation allowed deployments for rescue, natural disaster and humanitarian purposes, and argued that retaining the Triple Lock would not prevent Ireland from taking part in peacekeeping missions or modernising the Defence Forces.
On the Security Council veto, Stanley cited figures for UN resolutions between 2020 and 2024 and referred to a 1999 veto by China. He also argued that solemn national declarations attached to the Lisbon and Nice treaties, which he said were endorsed by the Irish people, protected the Triple Lock.

Stanley said successive opinion polls showed majority support for retaining Irish neutrality, which he described as a source of international credibility and a defence against aggression. He argued that any attempt to change the arrangements should require a referendum, and called for Ireland to work with other neutral countries to reform the UN and strengthen multilateralism.
The Bill and the Triple Lock
Stanley said the Bill was not a minor adjustment to defence and foreign policy, but a major change to Ireland’s position on international relations and the UN. He challenged the Government’s description of the proposals as reform of the Triple Lock, saying: “it's not reform of the Triple Lock, it's abolition of it.”
Peacekeeping and deployment claims
Stanley disputed claims that Ireland could not deploy more than 12 troops for rescue missions without UN Security Council approval. He said the legislation allowed deployments for rescue, natural disaster and humanitarian purposes, and argued that retaining the Triple Lock would not prevent Ireland from taking part in peacekeeping missions or modernising the Defence Forces.
UN vetoes and the treaty declarations
On the Security Council veto, Stanley cited figures for UN resolutions between 2020 and 2024 and referred to a 1999 veto by China. He also argued that solemn national declarations attached to the Lisbon and Nice treaties, which he said were endorsed by the Irish people, protected the Triple Lock.

Neutrality and public consent
Stanley said successive opinion polls showed majority support for retaining Irish neutrality, which he described as a source of international credibility and a defence against aggression. He argued that any attempt to change the arrangements should require a referendum, and called for Ireland to work with other neutral countries to reform the UN and strengthen multilateralism.
We publish thousands of recordings to make Irish politics transparent and resistant to manipulation. Spotted an error? Report it — together we are building a reliable archive of Irish politics.
Other speeches
Brian Stanley: Rents Soar - Market Can't Be Left Alone
Brian Stanley calls for toll and fare increases to be halted
Brian Stanley urges ban on disclosure of counselling notes
Brian Stanley on Housing Crisis: Urgent Call for State Housing Bond
Brian Stanley: 900 Children Waiting - Where Are the OTs?
Brian Stanley: Defence and Gardaí Cooperate on Cybersecurity
Tego samego dnia All speeches from this day →
Thomas Gould
Thomas Gould challenges Taoiseach on doubled house prices
Michael Fitzmaurice
Michael Fitzmaurice questions Ireland’s defence and foreign policy
George Lawlor
George Lawlor calls for help for clubs after Clearwater collapse
Micheál Martin
Micheál Martin apologises to Brian Stack’s family in Dáil
James Geoghegan
James Geoghegan challenges claims on peacekeeping bill
Seamus Healy
Seamus Healy: Triple Lock change must go to the people
Transcript
There needs to be a level of honesty about what you're putting forward here.
What's happening here is, and government is not being honest about it, you're doing away
with multilateralism and having UN approval.
So as Ireland can participate in what you have in the Bill is other regional arrangements
and relevant international forces.
Who defines that?
Who defines that?
The facts are this, is that your Bill, this Bill is not a small change or a modification
of defence and foreign policy, and it's misleading spin to say otherwise.
It's a complete change of position as a state in how we deal with international relations
and the UN.
And it's not reform of the Triple Lock, it's abolition of it.
But it's yet another move on top of what you've been doing for the last 20 years or so, yourselves
in Fine Gael, undermining our position as a neutral state.
This has included misinformation, the arms industry propaganda pumped out day after day,
participation in NATO missions, joint NATO missions, and the scandalous use of Shannon
Airport by the US war machine to carry out its illegal oil roars in the Middle East,
and you could go on and on.
This misinformation has included such nonsense as, from government ministers and spokespersons,
we can't deploy more than 12 troops, some of you were even saying that up to recently,
for rescue missions, et cetera, unless the UN Security Council approve it.
But of course we can, as confirmed by the minister many times, and as confirmed in the
legislation, that we can do that.
There's no limit on what can be deployed for missions on rescue, natural disaster, or humanitarian
purposes.
Another one is that we won't be able to participate in peacekeeping missions, but there are 11
active peacekeeping missions already in the world.
Or we need to modernize our defense forces.
Of course we do, and we shouldn't be leaving until now to do it.
That needed to be resourced, and it needed to be paid properly and modernized.
That should have happened.
None of that stops us from doing that.
Or that Russia will use the power of veto that the five members of the UN Security Council
have to block resolutions on peacekeeping.
Tell us which ones.
The facts are, there was only one in 1999 that was vetoed by China.
In fact, between 2020 and 2024, 264 UN resolutions were passed out of 284, there's only 20 rejected,
were passed by the UN Security Council without anyone exercising a veto.
We might just look at those facts for a minute.
And just on democracy, Minister, solemn national declarations, not wishy-washy statements,
solemn national declarations were attached to both Lisbon and Nice treaties and endorsed
by the Irish people to protect the Triple Lock.
The Triple Lock, Ministers, is wrote large in it.
Check the two declarations.
I've read them carefully.
It's there in them.
And that's how to protect our neutrality, which people were concerned about.
And any attempt to change the law or undo these national declarations by the sovereign
people, it's theirs to change only.
Without a referendum is a denial of democracy and a slap in the face to Irish citizens.
Despite the saturation levels of coverage to drop neutrality and the Triple Lock, successive
opinion polls show the majority of the electorate want to retain our neutrality.
Our neutrality has given us a level of credibility internationally.
It's our best defence against aggression because we don't pose a threat to other countries.
We should work with other neutral and underlying countries to build multilateralism.
And yes, the UN needs to be reformed and work to reform the UN and not join in with the
warmongers and the ones who are beating the war drums at the behest of the arms industries
and Western superpowers.