Paul Murphy: ‘You didn’t reform the Triple Lock’
Paul Murphy challenged the Government’s description of its proposed changes to the Triple Lock during a Dáil debate on Irish military neutrality. He argued that the changes would scrap a safeguard, weaken neutrality and make it easier for Ireland to take part in illegal wars.
Murphy said the Government was scrapping the Triple Lock rather than reforming it, and argued that Fianna Fáil’s mandate was to protect military neutrality while reforming the safeguard. He challenged the Minister to define neutrality, saying the Government’s approach reduced it to staying outside a military alliance.
He argued that the proposed change was connected to a wider effort to redefine Ireland’s neutrality and enable closer integration with a Western military alliance. He also questioned the claim that constitutional protection for neutrality would prevent Ireland from engaging with other countries on security and defence.

Murphy rejected the Government’s argument about a veto, saying the UN General Assembly would unlock the Triple Lock under the current legislation. He said the safeguard enshrined international law in Irish law and warned that removing it could allow Ireland to send troops to participate in illegal wars.
Murphy said the Government was scrapping the Triple Lock rather than reforming it, and argued that Fianna Fáil’s mandate was to protect military neutrality while reforming the safeguard. He challenged the Minister to define neutrality, saying the Government’s approach reduced it to staying outside a military alliance.
He argued that the proposed change was connected to a wider effort to redefine Ireland’s neutrality and enable closer integration with a Western military alliance. He also questioned the claim that constitutional protection for neutrality would prevent Ireland from engaging with other countries on security and defence.

We publish thousands of recordings to make Irish politics transparent and resistant to manipulation. Spotted an error? Report it — together we are building a reliable archive of Irish politics.
Other speeches
Paul Murphy demands 100% redress for homeowners with defects
Paul Murphy demands living wage and worker status for PhDs
Paul Murphy: Calls to Turn Off Recommender Algorithms
Paul Murphy warns against a permanent non-jury court
Paul Murphy Demands Debt Relief for Ukraine Now
Paul Murphy says EU nature restoration law is 'toothless'
Tego samego dnia All speeches from this day →
Sinéad Gibney
Sinéad Gibney: Triple lock removal threatens Irish neutrality
Barry Ward
Barry Ward backs removing the triple lock while defending neutrality
Brian Stanley
Brian Stanley: Triple Lock abolition is not reform
Dara Calleary
Dara Calleary: Government opposes Non-binary Recognition Bill
Claire Kerrane
Claire Kerrane: Stack family deserves truth and justice
Gary Gannon
Gary Gannon: Stack apology must lead to meaningful action
Transcript
I've seen a lot of dishonest and disingenuous arguments and debates in the Dáil in this
place.
I think this is the worst.
I really do.
I don't believe that you can possibly believe what you're saying.
You know what you're saying is not true.
The Minister over there is fond of saying over and over again that we're reforming the
Triple Lock.
And the reason he says it is because that's all you have a mandate for.
Fine Gael has no mandate whatsoever.
They didn't mention it.
The Independents, I'm sure, didn't mention it.
Fianna Fáil has a mandate to protect Irish military neutrality and to reform the Triple
Lock.
You're not telling the truth.
You're not telling the truth, Minister, when you pretend you're reforming something that
you're scrapping it.
Is anyone going to refer to the Triple Lock if you have your way with this?
Of course.
It'll be gone.
No one's going to call it the Triple Lock anymore.
If you have three locks and you get rid of one of them, it's not a Triple Lock anymore.
You didn't reform it.
Your own civil servants accepted it.
We're also meant to accept the idea that this has nothing to do with neutrality.
We're all meant to forget the discussions we had over the past years whereby the government
very openly said we want to have a discussion about neutrality, where Neil Martin said neutrality
is simply a policy issue which can change at any time, and called for a reflection on
military non-alignment in Ireland and our military neutrality.
Everyone with eyes to see knew what you were doing.
You took advantage of the situation created, the fear, by Putin's invasion of Ukraine to
try to scrap our neutrality.
You ran into strong public opinion, and so you simply devised a new tactic, which is
to redefine what neutrality is.
You listen to the Minister's speeches.
Neutrality simply means not joining NATO now.
That's all it means.
We could send troops to Iraq.
We could send troops to Iraq and we'd still be neutral, because you have simply redefined
neutrality as not joining a military alliance.
Will you give me your definition now?
You give me your definition.
Give me your definition of neutrality, Minister.
In your reply...
You have a rebuttal.
Because you have redefined neutrality as simply not being in a military alliance, and that
is not for no reason.
And then, interestingly and very worryingly, in the Senior Minister's speech today, when
she's telling us on the one hand that there's nothing to do with neutrality here, there's
no threat to neutrality, on the other hand, she says, putting neutrality in our constitution
would undoubtedly prevent us from engaging in any meaningful way with other countries
on security or defence matters.
What?
On the one hand, we're a neutral country, don't worry, there's no threat to neutrality,
but no, no, we can't actually put it in our constitution that governs what governments
can do, because that would prevent us engaging with other...
Who?
With NATO?
Would it be a problem to your participation almost every single month in METO's meeting
in NATO headquarters?
Would it be a problem with the agenda that anyone with eyes can see that Micheál Martin
is absolutely raring to have Ireland more and more integrated into a Western military
alliance?
Are we expected to forget that Micheál Martin signed up to facilitate the US invasion of
Right?
We're expected to forget all this now and we're just going to trust you.
No!
We don't trust you.
We don't trust governments that have supported US imperialist invasions, facilitated them
over decades.
Of course we don't trust you.
Finally, we have the red herring in terms of a veto.
It's a nonsense.
There's no veto.
The UN General Assembly would currently unlock the Triple Lock.
That's in the legislation as it currently is.
And all of this is framed with the idea that somehow a country is sovereign where it can
choose to send where it sends peacekeepers.
I'm sorry, that's not just the Triple Lock that stops you choosing where you send peacekeepers.
That's called international law.
International law says you can't just send troops wherever you want.
The UN Charter says you can't just send troops wherever you want.
What the Triple Lock does is enshrine international law in Irish law.
You want to get rid of it so you can send troops to participate in illegal wars.
You need to tell us which illegal wars you want us to participate in.
For more UN videos visit www.un.org