Michael Collins challenges Taoiseach over semi-state CEO pay rises
Michael Collins challenged the Taoiseach in Dáil Éireann over pay increases for chief executives of commercial semi-state bodies, contrasting them with pay rises for frontline public service workers. He sought answers on who approved the increases and argued that they were unfair while households face rising living costs and pressure on public services.
Collins cited increases including approximately €118,000 for the head of Uisce Éireann and almost €92,000 for the ESB chief executive. He also referred to increases at Bord na Móna and Dublin Bus, and asked the Taoiseach whether he, the Tánaiste or others in Government had signed off on the decisions.
Collins contrasted executive pay with increases of around 1% for frontline workers including nurses, teachers, special needs assistants, gardaí and firefighters. He linked the issue to the cost of fuel, home heating, groceries and household bills, saying families and pensioners were counting every euro.
He also raised water infrastructure failures, wastewater capacity and sewage entering rivers, questioning the value delivered by Uisce Éireann’s chief executive amid those problems. Collins argued that ordinary workers faced different rules from executives and called for accountability over the pay decisions.

The Taoiseach said CEO remuneration had not been systematically reviewed since 2011 and described the new framework as based on an independent committee’s report, with Government accepting its findings only in part. He argued that appropriate pay was needed to recruit and retain capable leaders, while also saying reviews should happen more regularly and pointing to Government measures on the cost of living.
CEO pay increases
Collins cited increases including approximately €118,000 for the head of Uisce Éireann and almost €92,000 for the ESB chief executive. He also referred to increases at Bord na Móna and Dublin Bus, and asked the Taoiseach whether he, the Tánaiste or others in Government had signed off on the decisions.
Frontline workers and household costs
Collins contrasted executive pay with increases of around 1% for frontline workers including nurses, teachers, special needs assistants, gardaí and firefighters. He linked the issue to the cost of fuel, home heating, groceries and household bills, saying families and pensioners were counting every euro.
Water services and accountability
He also raised water infrastructure failures, wastewater capacity and sewage entering rivers, questioning the value delivered by Uisce Éireann’s chief executive amid those problems. Collins argued that ordinary workers faced different rules from executives and called for accountability over the pay decisions.

The Taoiseach’s response
The Taoiseach said CEO remuneration had not been systematically reviewed since 2011 and described the new framework as based on an independent committee’s report, with Government accepting its findings only in part. He argued that appropriate pay was needed to recruit and retain capable leaders, while also saying reviews should happen more regularly and pointing to Government measures on the cost of living.
We publish thousands of recordings to make Irish politics transparent and resistant to manipulation. Spotted an error? Report it — together we are building a reliable archive of Irish politics.
Other speeches
Michael Collins: Calls for Adequate Staffing and Transparency
Michael Collins: Demands urgent change to rural planning rules
Michael Collins presses gov to cut bath rate after 612 closures
Michael Collins Slams Government Climate and Housing Plans
Michael Collins urges rethink on West Cork speed limit cuts
Michael Collins Calls Dáil Reform a 'Document of Destruction'
Tego samego dnia All speeches from this day →
Barry Andrews
Barry Andrews urges EU action to protect ICC judges
Malcolm Noonan
Malcolm Noonan: A right to thrive for people with disabilities
Ged Nash
Ged Nash: Ireland Has “Wasted a Boom”
Paul Murphy
Paul Murphy presses for Riverview school extension
Jen Cummins
Jen Cummins: Drug intimidation is trapping families at home
Conor D McGuinness
Conor D McGuinness asks for action on Waterford childcare gaps
Transcript
The people of this country are looking on with disbelief. At a time when families are
struggling to make ends meet, your government has approved a pay increase of approximately
118,000 for the CEO of Ishgardan, bringing his overall remuneration package to almost
392,000 a year. That is more than €2,270 extra every week. That's a 43% increase.
The CEO of ESB received a pay increase of almost 92,000, up 29% to 410,000 a year. Over
the morning, CEOs paid a rise of up to €75,000 to €300,000. Dublin's bus CEO paid a rise
of €60,000 to €260,000. Meanwhile, what did the nurse, special needs assistant, teacher,
guard and firefighter get? The people on the front line of the country received a pay increase
measured on around 1%, while semi-state executives received increases worth tens of thousands
of taxpayers' euros. The firefighter who runs into every burning building when everyone
else is running out. The nurse working throughout the night in an overcrowded emergency department.
The special needs assistant helping a child with additional needs. The guard answering
an emergency call. These are the people who keep Ireland functioning. Yet this government
tells them there are limits, that affordability matters, that the books have to balance. But
somehow, there is always money available at the top. Today, petrol costs almost £1.98
a litre, diesel is over £2.14 a litre and home heating oil is around £1.49 a litre.
Families feel those costs every day. When they walk into the supermarket, the basic
costs more and more. Bread, milk, butter, meat, vegetables and household essentials
have all become expensive. Working families, factory workers, farmers, fishermen, hauliers
and pensioners are counting every euro before they fill the car, heat the house or buy the
groceries. Yet, while ordinary people are struggling with the cost of living, your government
signs off on a pay rise worth more than £2,200 a week for the head of Aisge Aran. Which Minister
looked at these figures and thought they represented value for money? While communities across
the country are still dealing with water infrastructure failures, waste water capacity problems and
inadequate public services. In fact, the sewage systems are collapsing into our rivers
all over the country. Aisge Aran's CEO gets rewarded with a £118,000 increase a year
and is accountable to no one. What message does this send to the ordinary working people
of Ireland? Because from where they are standing, it looks like there is one set of rules for
hard working families, home helps, carers, council workers, RSS workers and another set
of rules entirely for those at the top. Can you explain to the people of the Middle Ireland
why they are expected to tighten their belts while this government rewards semi-state executives
with pay increases greater than many workers earn in an entire year? Taoiseach, who signed
off on this? Did you sign off on it? Did the Tanisha sign off on it? Did the independent
supporting this government know about these increases and support it? Taoiseach, who sanctioned
this immoral and unpatriotic payment?
First of all, I would say, Deputy, that prior to the work of the SPRC in 2025, there was
no systematic review of CEO pay in commercial estate bodies since 2011. So the issue hadn't
been looked at since 2011. And it was creating issues comparable in terms of recruiting people
for these bodies of a particular calibre, experience, expertise relative to what was
happening in the private sector. The government did agree a framework for the remuneration of
CEO pay in commercial estate bodies based on the findings of a report by the independent
senior posts remuneration committee, that's the SPRC. So an independent body was created
and asked to look at this independently, outside of government, to ascertain what would be
the levels of pay for CEOs. And what they recommended, government only accepted the
findings of the report in part, limiting pay to the market mean of comparable rules. So we didn't
take on board the full recommendations of this independent committee. And what the government
did was agreed the introduction of a banded salary structure for CEOs, ranging from their
current salary to the market median of the relevant band. And basically the report said you
need to have a fair, appropriate remuneration as a key element in the recruitment and retention
of CEOs of commercial estate bodies who are critical to the state's future development
and economic performance. These are enormous organisations now with huge budgets, huge
turnover, and very, very significant projects under their remit. And over the next five to six
years in particular, the ESB, you name them, will be overseeing very, very substantial investment
and delivering very significant projects, managing the funding and financing of those.
And that's the issue. The easier populist political position would be to do nothing.
But that actually in itself wouldn't serve the state either, Deputy, if the truth be told.
And we could enter into an era of complete mediocrity in terms of how commercial estate
bodies would be administered and governed and dealt with. And so the government didn't come up
with these increases itself. It didn't decide on them. But ultimately a decision has to be made in
terms of approving them. But the work was done independently of government and independent
of the relevant ministers on balance. And that's the background to it. And more broadly speaking,
we do have systems in terms of public service. We have national pay agreements.
What should happen here is there should be annual increases, in my view,
linked to inflation and so on, and that it shouldn't have to wait for another decade
or decade and a half before an area like this gets reviewed.
Thank you, Taoiseach. You said independent bodies outside of the government made a decision
and ye accepted in part. So are you saying ye accepted these increases? Because you're saying
that we should do nothing, that me, I suppose, at the other side here are saying we should do
nothing. I don't agree with that. Everybody deserves an increase. But an increase of 118,000
years old outrageous. The people of Ireland deserve accountability. They deserve answers.
And I'm not getting them here. To every hard-working taxpayer in Ireland, to every person
on a pension who can't afford to put home heating oil in the tank, to all those who have disabilities,
to those 350,000 who can't pay their electricity bills, to the highest amount of people ever in
this country who can't pay their mortgages. What do you think these moral increases to the CEOs
of Ischgairne, ESB, Bordamona and Dublin Bus mean to these people? Taoiseach, I'll tell you what it
means. Simply put to me by a taxpaying woman last night, if you're not at the top in this country,
the only way it pays to exist is to stay in bed. This is no longer a country for the hard-working
men and women. And again, I ask you Taoiseach, was it you, the Tánaiste and the independent
support in this government signed off on this shocking deal for those at the very top?
Thank you Deputy. Taoiseach to respond.
Deputy, first of all, I would make the overall point to you that it was decided independently
to assess what the post, the office or the position, not any individual, because individuals
come and go. But what does the position at the head of a given commercial estate body,
what would be a fair increase? You're saying yourself there should be increases. This wasn't
looked at since 2011. And in my view, that shouldn't happen again. It should be looked at
far more regularly than it was. And we have reduced, by the way, people on higher incomes
will pay far more higher tax. That's right. We have a very progressive tax system in this
far more than those in middle and low incomes. And that's the way it should be. And it will
continue that way. But we've also done a lot on the cost of living, by the way, Deputy.
And we've over the last five years in particular, intervened every year,
significantly to try and protect people, working people. This year in the budget,
we reduced income tax. We've now reduced child care costs. Thank you Taoiseach.
We've brought in a new cost of disability payments. We've taken a lot of measures on
the cost of living side. Thank you Taoiseach.
That concludes