Mary Lou McDonald: Budget leaves workers and families behind
Sinn Féin leader Mary Lou McDonald criticised the Government’s budget in Dáil Éireann, arguing that it fails to address the pressures facing workers, families and young people. She called for a different approach, with investment in affordable homes, healthcare, education and the cost of living.

We publish thousands of recordings to make Irish politics transparent and resistant to manipulation. Spotted an error? Report it — together we are building a reliable archive of Irish politics.
Other speeches
Tego samego dnia All speeches from this day →
Victor Boyhan
Victor Boyhan Calls for Food Vision 2030 Debate
Ivana Bacik
Ivana Bacik: Budget Fails Struggling Households, Says Labour
Seán Kelly
Seán Kelly Calls for Release of Iranian Political Prisoners
Diarmuid Wilson
Diarmuid Wilson: Neutrality Debate Must Focus on Defence Capacity
Sorca Clarke
Sorca Clarke Challenges Budget on Childcare and Living Costs
Darragh O'Brien
Darragh O'Brien Sets Out Budget 2027 Energy and Transport Plans
Transcript
I would be right to say that it is up to you to work and get involved in this movement.
At the same time, it is not just about Fianna Fáil and Fianna Gàidheal, but about the same thing again.
It is up to you to look at the bigger picture and to make a difference in the world.
There is no doubt about it.
There is no doubt about it.
There is no doubt about the challenges we are facing,
nor about how we can get out of them.
There is a lot more to say about Fianna Fáil and Fianna Gàidheal.
It is not up to you to make a difference in the world,
and to make a better and more equitable world.
This speech was delivered yesterday by Ministers Simon Harris and Jack Chambers.
I was wondering if the two men would come up to the mark and meet the clear challenges before them.
If they would bring vision, purpose and real solutions for workers and families,
because God knows people need that now more than ever.
This is a wealthy state.
The economy is very strong, and yet something doesn't quite add up for people.
In fact, people know that something is very badly wrong.
Because despite that wealth and economic strength,
too many ordinary people, workers, families, our young people,
are locked out of prosperity and opportunity.
Too many households are under enormous pressure just to get by.
People are exhausted, and who could blame them?
Prices keep going up.
The bills keep rolling in.
The rip-off is never-ending.
And people are sick of it.
Sick of working harder than ever, but still falling further behind.
This was a year of record tax receipts,
and Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael never tire of boasting about the massive surpluses.
But the questions that people ask themselves every day,
and that they ask now after this budget, are very simple.
Why is it so expensive to live in Ireland and raise a family?
Why can't working people afford a home?
Why are renters paying rip-off record rents?
Why are hospitals overcrowded, A&Es under daily pressure,
and close to a million patients on waiting lists?
Why are people with disabilities left behind?
Kids with special needs left without a school place,
or left waiting for assessment of needs or therapies?
These were the questions on my mind as the ministers read out their speeches,
and as Simon's 45 minutes rolled into Jack's 45,
as they talked in millions and billions.
I wasn't just angry.
I thought, how painfully out of touch with the lives of ordinary people can you possibly get?
You see, we've now had a decade of the Fianna Fáil-Fine Gael partnership government.
This is the 11th Fianna Fáil-Fine Gael budget,
and I realised that I've listened to a different version of the same budget 11 times now.
Sure, the ministers change, the numbers change, the speeches change,
but the one thing that never, ever changes
is that Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael always put those at the top first.
The golden circles ahead of the ordinary worker and families of Ireland,
the people who actually create the wealth.
And as the minister's speeches gave way to the arrogant racket of applause
and back-slapping from the government benches,
I thought, is that it? Really?
Here you are with your billions and billions, with your record surpluses,
and is this the best that you could do?
A gone-before-you-get-it budget,
devoid of imagination, devoid of ambition,
so disconnected, the product of an inability to listen
or to understand what workers and families are going through.
Nothing here that says solutions, solutions, solutions.
Instead, people got half-measures, tinkering at the edges,
or nothing at all.
I will say this, if your aim was to show people again
that Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael don't have the answers
or the ideas to meet the challenges or the opportunities that our people face,
well then you get an A1, top of the class and job done.
Simon Harris couldn't stop saying that this would be a budget
for those who get up early and work hard.
But who exactly were you talking to when you said that?
It certainly wasn't the majority of workers,
the one and a half million workers that you left behind yesterday
with your tax changes.
200 quid, that's what you gave them,
not even a fiver a week, a pittance,
that'll be righted out with just one household bill,
and you act as though people should be grateful.
Did you think they'd jump for joy, Tánaiste,
when you unveiled a second budget in a row
that leaves ordinary workers worse off?
This is actually an insult to those workers.
We showed you a fairer way to give every single worker
a real income tax boost,
by abolishing USC on the first €40,000 for every worker.
But you ignored that, again.
A full decade after Fine Gael promised to scrap the USC entirely,
the tax brought in by Fianna Fáil when you crashed the economy,
do you remember that, Micheál?
But you've barely made a dent in it.
What do you think families struggling to keep up with soaring prices
heard from you yesterday?
Two weeks ago, the Tánaiste Minister for Finance stood here,
puffed out his chest and told people not to worry
because, and I quote,
help is on the way.
Well, what help?
No dedicated cost of living package.
More than 300,000 households already can't pay their electricity bills.
One million households are on the hook for further energy price hikes.
And nothing to help them pay their bills.
We asked you to provide the €400 energy credit.
You couldn't find the money for it, you say.
But you did find the money for generous tax breaks
for your pals in high places.
The developers, the landlords, the bankers, all the usual suspects.
No sign of a windfall tax to hit the bumper profits
of the big energy companies.
Companies who squeeze every euro they can from their customers.
You left them off scot-free.
You didn't put a glove on them.
And what of the 700,000 families
who rely on home heating oil to keep warm?
After months of standing back and refusing to help,
what do you come up with?
A miserly €43 cut on a fill of oil
that now costs €1,600.
Yes, €1,600.
That took some neck.
You could have removed all of the carbon tax from home heating oil.
That would have delivered a substantial price cut.
But again, for Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael,
it seems these families simply aren't worth that effort.
And it's the same when it comes to families who rely on a car.
Rely on a car.
Petrol and diesel prices are through the roof.
They're up to €2.20 a litre in some parts of the country.
And that is a huge daily pressure on households.
And yet you did nothing to get those prices down.
You could have delivered a further €0.10 per litre reduction.
That's what Sinn Féin proposed.
But now we know you have learned nothing
from the mass protests in the spring.
We know that you are not listening again
because you're prepared to allow people to continue to take that hit.
Now, maybe none of this makes a difference
to the people in this chamber,
all of whom are very, very well paid.
But it means a hell of a lot
to the person out there trying to build a life,
to parents trying to provide for their kids,
families trying to keep the show on the road,
pensioners trying to pay their bills,
and to young people wondering if they will have to leave.
Yesterday, after you announced your dead-end budget,
I asked myself, what actually is the point of this government?
How is it that it's always lost on you
that it's your job to make ordinary people's lives better?
Your job is not to continually feather the nest of those at the top.
But that is the Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael way,
and it's written all over this budget again.
You could have, and you should have, made better choices.
You could have shown some courage
to break the mundane cycle of a century.
You could have put workers and families first.
You see, you have the money,
and you could transform things, but you don't want to.
And that's the truth.
In fact, you act as though providing investment
for the things that really matter to people
is somehow reckless and a waste of public money.
Well, let me tell you,
nobody is asking you to build thousands of your bike sheds.
We leave that to you guys.
We are talking about building homes that people can afford,
investing in our health service
so that people get care when they need it,
in our schools, in making life affordable,
in building communities and lifting children out of poverty,
driving opportunity and opening prosperity for everyone.
That could be done.
But once again, Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael prove beyond doubt
that they will never, ever get us there.
I want to ask the Tánaiste and Minister Chambers,
what do you think our young people heard from your budget?
The 7 in 10 of Ireland's sons and daughters
who are now looking at leaving for a better life abroad.
What did your budget say to them?
At the election, Simon Harris,
you told them that you'd abolish student fees.
But after your budget,
students are still paying €350 more today
than when you made that promise.
You take these people for fools, Tánaiste,
but let me assure you, they can do the maths.
They know, at the rate you're going,
it will take 16 years to scrap student fees.
So that means children not born today
will be preparing for the leaving certificate
before we get there.
Sinn Féin would have immediately cut student fees
by €1,250 and completely abolish them
by September of next year.
Because that is the right, the progressive
and the strategic thing to do.
And what of the young renters of Ireland?
A measly €150,
while rents continue to spiral out of control.
This penny-pinching, I have to say,
is in stark contrast to your tax breaks for big developers.
Or the sweetheart deal
that you have disgracefully, shamefully continued
in this budget for vulture funds.
The one, you know the one,
the one that allows them away without paying
one single cent of tax on their rental income.
That sweetheart deal.
And I had to laugh earlier at Micheál Martin,
and I don't generally laugh at him, I can assure you.
He talked about being responsible stewards
of the public money in a very lofty, high-minded way.
Well my God, is that your definition
of being a responsible steward of the public money?
I would guess that the public are not one bit happy
if they actually realise
that these funds get away without paying
a single cent in tax on their rental income.
Our proposal, the responsible proposal,
was to end that scheme.
And that would raise €335 million.
And that money pays for €10 a day childcare
with change left over.
And you remember that because that was another big promise
you made before the last election.
But again, our young people see you,
and young parents see you,
choose the big boys over the public good.
This budget, as regards housing,
isn't about young people.
It's a blueprint for the continuation of a crisis
that's actually pushing them out.
And we simply cannot have another generation
of our young scattered to the four corners.
We've had too much of that in the past.
Young people must be able to build their future
here in Ireland.
This is where they belong.
This is their country.
This is their home.
And their talent, their creativity, their skills
will take us forward.
We simply cannot lose them.
So we stand here today,
not only to criticise your go-nowhere budget,
we stand here to plant a flag
for our young people and their future.
For a future beyond this stifling roundabout repetition
of broken Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael policies.
Enough of going around in circles.
Our young people deserve their chance,
their opportunity to build a good life here in Ireland.
And we will keep fighting for them.
And we will never, ever give up.
What do you think people with disabilities
heard yesterday from your budget?
Because it doesn't come even close to giving them
the support that they need, that they are entitled to.
How many times have they stood in the rain
outside the Dáil, protesting,
just to try and get your government to listen?
And now, after all your consultations
and your heel-dragging, this is what you come up with.
A lousy ten euro a week.
That won't even begin to make a dent
in the additional expenses that people with disabilities face
every single day.
A 500 euro lump-sum payment,
one, by the way, that excludes people with disabilities
who are working. That's just wrong.
And furthermore, it won't be paid out
until the spring of next year.
And meanwhile, your cost of disability scheme
is pushed out again until 2028.
Wait. That's your message.
That's always the message to the disabled.
Wait, wait, wait.
Struggle, struggle, struggle.
Count Corley, the budget is often viewed
as something that happens in a political bubble.
But the choices make real impacts
on people's lives.
You see, I remember very, very clearly
the austerity budgets after the economic crash.
I remember when times were lean,
when the cupboard was bare,
how Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael acted with razor-sharp pace,
real energy, real decisiveness
when it came to delivering vicious cuts for working people.
There was no limit to your imagination
in doling out the pain.
When you scrapped the bereavement grant,
when you cut respite care,
when you cut JobSeeker's Allowance for young people.
But here we are now
in this time of abundance.
The state has never had so much money.
So I ask you, where now
is that same pace, that energy, that imagination
from Fine Gael and Fianna Fáil
to improve the lives of working people
and our young?
Could it be that in fact, in the end,
it's not the economic circumstances that matter?
It's simply that these parties,
your parties, that have clung to power for a century
have no interest in delivering
for workers and families.
Ever. Irrespective of the circumstances.
You see, you're wedded to a politics
that's all about protecting the privilege
and the wealth of those at the top.
And that's never going to change.
So, Ken Corley, I want to speak to all of those left out,
forgotten and abandoned by this budget.
And they are many.
You deserve so much better than this.
And we are on your side. We have your backs.
And we will continue to fight your corner
and we will not stop.
Because we believe, we know, that we can shape
a better country and a better future.
That life in Ireland can be affordable.
That we can build the homes that our people need.
We can have a healthcare system that works.
Affordable childcare. Education open for every child.
And opportunity for our young people.
And I know that right now that could seem
really, really far away.
But Ireland is a great country and we are a great people.
And our best days are yet to come.
So don't give up.
Don't lose hope.
Because it doesn't have to be Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael
budgets forever.
It doesn't have to be Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael government forever.
So on this side we will keep working hard
to build the strong Republican
alternative.
To win your trust. To win your confidence.
To show you how things can be different.
How things can be better.
How we can have an Ireland, a united Ireland
that puts workers and families first.
Godspeed that day.
Thank you.