Ken O'Flynn says budget fails hard-working people
Independent Ireland TD Ken O'Flynn criticised the Government’s budget during a Dáil Éireann debate, arguing that tax changes and cost pressures leave hard-working people and pensioners short-changed. He called for the Universal Social Charge and carbon tax on home heating fuels to be scrapped, and challenged the Government over spending, inheritance tax and infrastructure in Cork.
O'Flynn pointed to PRSI increases, bus fares and the continuing Universal Social Charge, which he said was introduced as a temporary measure in 2011. He argued that the budget’s changes did not amount to abolishing the charge, and said Independent Ireland would phase it out over five years.
He criticised Government overspending, citing a €700 million overrun and the Fiscal Council of Ireland’s warning that it could reach €1 billion. O'Flynn also challenged the pension increase, describing the budget’s approach as “pure stagecraft”.
O'Flynn said the support announced for heating costs fell well short of the increase in kerosene prices. He welcomed the Government’s move to cut carbon tax on home heating oil and gas, while urging it to go further and scrap the tax. He also argued that single-person households and relatives inheriting from an aunt, uncle or other family member face unfair treatment.

O'Flynn raised concerns about young people considering leaving Ireland and farmers planning to leave the sector. He also questioned the attention given to Cork infrastructure in a budget that included €6 billion for Metrolink. Watch the recording to hear the full contribution.
Tax and everyday costs
O'Flynn pointed to PRSI increases, bus fares and the continuing Universal Social Charge, which he said was introduced as a temporary measure in 2011. He argued that the budget’s changes did not amount to abolishing the charge, and said Independent Ireland would phase it out over five years.
Government spending and pensioners
He criticised Government overspending, citing a €700 million overrun and the Fiscal Council of Ireland’s warning that it could reach €1 billion. O'Flynn also challenged the pension increase, describing the budget’s approach as “pure stagecraft”.
Heating costs and tax fairness
O'Flynn said the support announced for heating costs fell well short of the increase in kerosene prices. He welcomed the Government’s move to cut carbon tax on home heating oil and gas, while urging it to go further and scrap the tax. He also argued that single-person households and relatives inheriting from an aunt, uncle or other family member face unfair treatment.

Young people, farmers and Cork infrastructure
O'Flynn raised concerns about young people considering leaving Ireland and farmers planning to leave the sector. He also questioned the attention given to Cork infrastructure in a budget that included €6 billion for Metrolink. Watch the recording to hear the full contribution.
We publish thousands of recordings to make Irish politics transparent and resistant to manipulation. Spotted an error? Report it — together we are building a reliable archive of Irish politics.
Other speeches
Ken O'Flynn: Challenges Taoiseach on Nuclear Ban vs Imports
Ken O'Flynn: Calls 21-Page Plan 'Sticking Plaster'
Ken O'Flynn challenges heating tax rises for coal users
Ken O'Flynn Challenges Removing Three-Day Reflection Safeguard
Ken O'Flynn: Movement Hijacked, Tricolour for All
Ken O'Flynn Challenges Carbon Tax and Heating Oil Costs
Tego samego dnia All speeches from this day →
Duncan Smith
Duncan Smith says Help to Buy is pushing house prices up
James Lawless
James Lawless sets out €1 tobacco duty rise
Martin Heydon
Martin Heydon outlines inheritance tax threshold increases
David Cullinane
David Cullinane: Government is out of touch on fuel costs
Michael Collins
Michael Collins says budget fails households under pressure
Michael Healy-Rae
Michael Healy-Rae: Budget welcomes, but more work is needed
Transcript
Thank you Lost Count Corla. People say a lot about the Minister of Finance and some people in this
house have said he has no sense of humour but I must disagree entirely with that legend or fact.
He stood up here and he made an absolute joke of the entire budget.
The state has taken in three billion extra euro in corporation tax in September alone
and both ministers have borrowed the phrase from Leo Vadkar and the old good old line
this is a budget for people that get up early in the morning.
And they do Minister, they do get up early in the morning, they get up early in the morning
to pay a charge from 2011 that's still going, a temporary one.
They get up early in the morning to pay a carbon tax on the diesel that gets them to work
and they're getting up early in the morning for the bus fare that takes that is now up 15%
in effective January. Last Thursday five days before this budget the PRSI went up again
and for the 400,000 workers earning 35,000 to 44,000 euros that's about 250 euros a year.
Well done that's barely five euros a week. That's not a reward for getting up early in the morning
that's an alarm clock. The Minister said today that this budget was for hard-working people
and people were doing their best. They are Keown, they are doing their best but this budget does
not do its best for its people. Take the universal social charge brought in by the Fianna Fáil
administration in 2011 and sold as a temporary measure for the tax for an emergency time.
The emergency ended long ago but the charges still remain. It has outlasted four Taoiseachs
and it is working on its fifth. Today the Minister moved one band by 1600 euros.
That's not abolishing a temporary charge it's maintaining that charge. Independent Ireland
would have phased out that completely within five years and we wouldn't have had to pay for it by
by taking tax from somewhere else but by purely cutting the waste of this government. Because
there is waste in this government. You've already spent over spent 700 million euros this year and
Fiscal Council of Ireland have said it could reach the entire 1 billion. Today the Minister
announced a task force for looking for waste. Well I can save you the trouble Minister. Start
with looking at the HSE agency bill, the National Children's Hospital. They found the money to
overspend and overspend well. Minister I would say to you you do not need a task force but this
government need a mirror. Let's look at our pensioners. Fianna Fáil promised the pensioners
of this country 24 months ago 350 euros a week. After today they'll get 309 euros 30 and they
will get a 10 euro increase in total. Because what did you do? You were cut planning it and you said
you flaunted the idea of 7 euros 50 first. You leaked it out there and then when you frightened
people then you said actually we're going to come up with 10 euros and this government waited
for the applause. That's not generosity. That is pure stagecraft by this government. Today at
Royal Ireland a fill of kerosene is 700 euros more than it was last year. The budget tasks
30 or 40 to 50 euros taking it off and another 140 euros in fuel allowance if you're lucky enough
to get fuel allowance. That's 700 euros up and 180 euros back at its best. That's not relief.
That's just rounding an error. Today the government has cut carbon tax on home heating oil and gas
and promised not to rise it again. Independent Ireland refused to go in with this government
because of that tax. So Minister welcome to our position in Independent Ireland Minister. Now
finish the job and scrap the tax. Look at a different point of this budget. One in five
households in this country are single persons. They can't share a tax band and they have to
pay every bill alone. This government has finally admitted living alone costs more than it does
for anybody else. Living alone costs more for pensioners and the
worker living alone gets absolutely nothing. And of course let us not forget the childless couple
or the single man or single woman that wants to leave their home to a niece or a nephew. The
niece or a nephew will now pay three times more tax than a son or a daughter would. Today a son
or a daughter got 20,000 euros more tax free in inheritance tax. A niece or a nephew will receive
4,000 euros in this budget. That widens the gap of inequity and it deepens the division.
In 1980 Charles J. Hottie at least had the honesty to tell this house we're living far beyond our
means. Today nearly seven in ten of the young people are thinking about leaving our shores
and not returning. One in three farmers ministers plan to leave farming in the next five years.
Minister you say this budget is not to mortgage the next generation's future
but minister this is the next generation of this country cannot afford a mortgage.
Six billion euros on Metrolink and only a couple of lines mentioned about Cork. A Taoiseach is a
cork man whose government has to look at the infrastructure of this country and you'd swear
to God that this government doesn't lend at all.