Brian Stanley: Affordable and Cost Rental Homes Must Scale Up
Brian Stanley called for more affordable purchase and cost rental homes during housing questions in Dáil Éireann. He said schemes must better serve workers who earn too much for social housing but cannot secure a mortgage, and urged the Government to expand local access to cost rental homes.
We publish thousands of recordings to make Irish politics transparent and resistant to manipulation. Spotted an error? Report it — together we are building a reliable archive of Irish politics.
Other speeches
Brian Stanley Warns Rent Bill Is a 'Charter for Misery'
Brian Stanley questions distribution of Just Transition funding
Brian Stanley presses on NATO role and triple lock referendum
Brian Stanley: Demands NCSE Plan Be Scrapped Over SNA Cuts
Brian Stanley: We Cannot Afford Not to Reunify Ireland
Brian Stanley presses Taoiseach on delayed wind farm rules
Tego samego dnia All speeches from this day →
James Browne
James Browne Says Housing Referendum Would Distract from Delivery
Gerard P. Craughwell
Gerard P. Craughwell Questions Ireland’s Cyber Resilience
Victor Boyhan
Victor Boyhan Seeks Debate on FOI and Open Government Data
Danny Healy-Rae
Danny Healy-Rae presses for green diesel support for construction
Ged Nash
Ged Nash: Government accused of ‘fraudulent budgeting’
Brendan Smith
Brendan Smith calls for higher social housing income limits
Transcript
The question I have for the Housing Ministers and local government is to increase the number
of affordable housing units that can be bought and provided by local authorities. We need
that affordable housing scheme to be referenced to people who are working hard. I have them
coming to me, I suppose everybody has them coming, all TDs and Councillors have them
coming to us. We need to get housing solutions for these people who cannot get on a local
authority housing waiting list because of the income threshold on the one hand and on
the other hand they cannot obtain a loan from a private lending institution. We need to
fix this problem.
Thank you very much and I thank Deputy Stanley for his questions in relation to increasing
the number of affordable to buy housing units provided by local authorities and plans to
increase the number of cost of rental units that will be provided in schemes by local
authorities as well. I propose taking both of these questions, PQs 101 and 102 together.
Providing affordable and high-quality homes for purchase and long-term rental is at the
centre of the government's housing policy and our housing plan delivering homes, buildings
and communities.
The housing plan reinforces and expands the range of existing affordable housing measures
being implemented by the government, in particular a new starter homes programme which is a central
component of the plan and aims to deliver an average of 15,000 affordable housing supports
annually to 2030, including starter purchase homes and cost rental homes. To independent
delivery of the starter homes programme, the government is investing an unprecedented level
of funding by way of a package of direct exchequer-funded affordability measures, additional investment
through the Land Development Agency and lending by the Housing Finance Agency.
In terms of delivery, starter purchase homes and cost rental homes are being delivered
at scale across the country and in a partnership with not only the local authorities but also
the Land Development Agency and the approved housing bodies. It is through this ambitious
network of partnership that the government was able to deliver almost 9,300 starter purchase
and cost rental homes in 2025 and is on target to exceed this in 2026. Total exchequer capital
investment in the starter homes in 2025 was just over £1 billion, with a further £1.2
billion available this year. This is a huge level of investment.
To support the delivery of starter homes by local authorities, specifically the Affordable
Housing Fund is open to applications and available to support all local authorities
to deliver starter purchase and cost rental homes in their local area. The Affordable
Housing Fund subsidy is also available as a direct subvention on local authority housing
development costs at rates of £50,000, £75,000 and £100,000 per starter purchase home, depending
on the density of housing units per hectare on the development and its location. In addition,
a higher rate of Affordable Housing Fund subsidy of £150,000 per home is available to support
the delivery of cost rental homes in the five cities. Ninety-five per cent of the approved
subsidy is met from exchequer funds via the Affordable Housing Fund scheme, and the remaining
five per cent subsidy is paid by the local authority concerned from its own funds.
To date, the funding of over £766 million has been approved from the Affordable Housing
Fund and, as a precursor, the Service Sites Fund for 27 local authorities to support the
delivery of over 8,400 affordable purchase and cost rental homes. This includes the approval
of 30 starter purchase homes in the Deputy's own county of Leith, with all of these homes
to be delivered by the end of 2026. Overall, since 2022 to end Q1 2026, over 3,100 local
authority starter purchase and cost rental homes have been delivered, and the local authority
starter home delivery programme continues to expand as new opportunities for affordable
housing delivery are identified and developed.
To further support the expansion of starter home delivery nationwide, since the beginning
of 2026, Roscommon, Cabin, Donegal and Tipperary have received approvals to deliver their first
local authority starter purchase homes schemes. The approvals support the commitment under
the Programme for Government Action 7.5 in delivering homes, building communities to
work with local authorities to bring forward Affordable Housing Fund proposals in areas
that do not currently have projects in place.
In addition to delivering homes and building communities, local authorities have commenced
the updating of their housing delivery action plans for review by my department, setting
out how the starter homes programme will be implemented within their area. Each housing
delivery action plan will be informed by identifiable affordable housing needs within their area
and will include the collaboration with their delivery partners, including the Land Development
Agency and the approved housing bodies as applicable. These plans will be completed
and published by local authorities later in the year, and help determine what is needed
and help drive delivery of that out to the end of the decade.
Furthermore, measures such as the First Home Scheme and Help to Buy Scheme and vacant property
refurbished grants and ready-to-build schemes are also available.
The median price of a house in leash has gone up 16.8% in one year. The reality is
that the target given by your department, which I have here, is 38 affordable and cost
rentals, affordable to buy and cost rentals, to be done in leash over a five-year period.
It is minuscule. I would not even make a dent in the numbers that we need. The demand
is massive. As it happens, the County Council, when we were down at the launch of some of
these, directly delivered over 90, and there are 62 more in the pipeline. You are at the
Dargan Woods launch, good houses, and I want to raise a point about that. The scheme needs
to be expanded to meet the demands of households whose income are over that threshold for social
housing, but do not qualify for a mortgage or cannot get a mortgage. These are workers
and households. These are the real squeezed middle, and they are typically trapped in
private rented accommodation paying sky-high rents. I gave you the median price. It had
an increase of 16.8%. It is now for one-, two-, and three-bedroom homes in leash, £248,000.
The scheme needs to be expanded. One other point I want to make in relation to the cost
rentals. This is not about being parochial, but you have a situation. You are there for
the launch of Dargan Woods. Some of the people, because of the way they are advertised, Minister,
and the way that you can apply from anywhere, you have people now who move from Dublin who
are in a cost rental in Dargan Woods. They are now commuting to Dublin. Some local workers
who work in the county leash applied for them, but they did not get in first, and they missed
out. They are now caught in a situation where they cannot get a house in the locality. In
the interest of trying to reduce commuting, in terms of trying to get people living where
they are working, not to be parochial, we need to open the schemes to people within
the county in the first instance. I would ask that your Department would look at that,
Thank you very much, Last Councillor. I thank the Deputy again for his important questions
in relation to affordable to buy housing units and also cost rental units. As the Deputy knows,
Leash has an excellent record in terms of delivering homes. It is one of the stronger
counties, and I think Leash is benefiting from taking that lead in terms of delivering homes.
It will benefit it also in the medium and long term, economically, as well as the key benefit
of providing roofs over people's heads. I wish every local authority would deliver homes at
the rate that Leash is doing. Nonetheless, we know we have an awful lot more to do. We need to
work harder in collaboration with Leash, because people in Leash are obviously under pressure as
well and continue to be under pressure to get a housing solution for them. I very much hear the
Deputy's concerns and his proposals and ideas. We want to ensure that everybody can get access
to a home that is within their ability to afford it, be that social, affordable or private delivery.
It is important to be able to stay in their own local community. The Deputy talks about people
commuting, but I want people to be able to stay in their own local communities. That is why,
for example, we are changing the rules around rural one-off housing. We have the very same
example that the Deputy is talking about, where people are living in towns because they cannot
live in the rural area where they have grown up and where their families are, and driving back
to work on farms or driving back out to look after their family. We have more work to do,
and I very much acknowledge that. We are making significant changes and significant differences,
and we will continue to work on them.
You saw yourself the house in Darkwoods. It is good quality, and the council have exceeded the
Government's targets by nearly 250%. You do need to increase your targets,
that is the first thing I would say to you, both for affordable and cost rental.
There are a huge number of inquiries. In relation to cost rental,
this is the only option for a lot of workers and households. People in their 40s, 50s and 60s,
a lot of them come out of broken relationships or separated or whatever,
and other circumstances. They cannot get a loan because of age. They do not qualify
for a council house because of the income. Then there is another group, low-paid workers in their
20s, 30s and 40s, who again are above the limit but will never be able to get that mortgage to
buy. They need to be helped with cost rental. We cannot condemn them to a full lifetime,
including going into pension years. This is the key point, going into pension years
in private rented accommodation. That is not fair in a balanced society.
The cost rental is a scheme some of us here advocated back 10 years ago when it was not
even on the radar. Others have come to it now. I welcome that. It removes the profit fraction.
It is a sustainable model. The finance is paid back. There is no long-term hit here for the
state. It is a good scheme, good quality housing. People say a lot of it is apartments or small
square metres. That is fine. It has done the job for the 12 years I have lived in it.
It is very important. People often say small houses in Drimley or Cabra or wherever else.
It is not to go backwards. You can have modern houses that are compact and meet people's needs,
but we need to provide affordable and cost rental at scale. That is the message I am trying to say.
You need to increase your targets. You also need to reduce the cost.
If you go back again and dust down the Kenny report, or have another Kenny report implemented,
to reduce the land cost and bring down the price of housing.
I hear the Deputy's concerns for his constituents not being able to have a housing solution
that they can afford. The Deputy is right. We have to have multiple housing solutions for people.
People at a certain age are not going to find it extremely difficult to get a mortgage,
even with the mortgage supports out there. Mortgage times are given for people.
As you get older, your repayment time gets squeezed and the repayments go up. It is harder
to get a mortgage. I very much hear the Deputy's concerns for his constituents.
We will continue to work to ensure that there are those solutions put in place
right across the country, in every constituency,
that people need to be able to stay in their own local communities.