Menu
VideoParliament
VideoParliament Irish politics in one place — download the app
Get app
VideoParliament
VideoParliament for Windows Get the desktop app — notifications about new speeches
Get app
Jennifer Whitmore Demands Windfall Tax on Energy Profits

Jennifer Whitmore Demands Windfall Tax on Energy Profits

Social Democrats TD Jennifer Whitmore has called for a windfall tax on energy companies, a targeted €400 energy credit and greater investment in solar power during a Dáil Éireann exchange with the Tánaiste. She said more than half a million households are in arrears on gas and electricity bills while energy company profits continue to rise.
Jennifer Whitmore — still from remarks: Jennifer Whitmore Demands Windfall Tax on Energy Profits (24.09.2026)

We publish thousands of recordings to make Irish politics transparent and resistant to manipulation. Spotted an error? Report it — together we are building a reliable archive of Irish politics.

Tego samego dnia All speeches from this day →

Transcript
Tá naiste, there are now more than half a million households in arrears on their gas and electricity bills. That number has never been higher and it is continuing to soar. Hundreds and thousands of people all over the country who are facing a cold and bleak winter, who feel a rising sense of dread every single time a bill comes through their door. Many of these people have never had problems paying bills before but now, despite scrimping and saving, they are simply unable to make their budgets go any further. At the same time, as more and more people go into arrears on their bills, the profits of energy companies are booming. Just last week, the ESB announced that profits for the first half of the year were up 100 million euros. Their CEO is in line for a pay hike of an eye-watering 161,000 euros. This gives some indication of the bonanza that energy companies are enjoying. This is all happening while their very own customers are going cold. This is not sustainable, it is not fair and it is not right. It is time the Government stopped hand-wringing and actually did something about it. A windfall tax on the super profits of energy companies needs to be introduced now to stop this immoral profiteering. This is money that could be used to provide support for those who need it most, a 400 euro targeted energy credit for low and middle income earners, to give them some immediate relief from skyrocketing bills as they face into a very difficult winter. But the budget needs to go further than that. We all know that Trump caused the war in Iran and the global energy shocks that arose from it, but it is your Government that has left households so exposed to these energy price shocks by failing to invest, by failing to support them become resilient and to move away from fossil fuels. You have failed to invest in solar to the extent that you should have. We should be front-loading investments in solar panels which can be installed quickly and easily and they bring costs down immediately. That would mean at least a saving of 450 euro on bills this year, next year and every year after. The Social Democrats have a solar for all plan that we are asking you to adopt. Double the grants for solar panels, introduce a grant for battery storage and make solar panels free for households most at risk of fuel poverty and as well as finally, please roll out plug-in solar. This is what we need to see, some ambition from this Government instead of the usual tinkering around the edges. Can you tell me, do you agree that it is immoral for energy companies to make windfall profits during an energy crisis? Will you introduce a windfall tax on their super profits? Will you introduce a 400 euro energy credit for low and middle income families and will you radically ramp up solar? Thanks very much to Deputy Whitmore and I join with you in welcoming our constituents from Blessington Community College. Good to have you all here too. A couple of points that I want to respond to. Firstly, in relation to a windfall energy tax, I believe there is significant merit in looking at a windfall energy tax and it's not about commenting on that. I chaired a meeting on it in Dublin Castle last week with all European counterparts. We've tasked the European Commission with doing a body of work and reporting back to the ECOFIN, to the European meeting of finance ministers which will take place on, from my memory, the Thursday and Friday of budget week. I do believe it's best to approach these issues at a European level. That's how we approached it in the past when you recall we legislated for a framework and indeed put in place a tax at the start of the Ukraine situation after the brutal illegal Russian invasion of Ukraine. Because there are some companies who are benefiting very significantly from profits, not because they're enterprising or innovative, just because the Strait of Hormuz is shut. Therefore, I think there is a compelling case. I do think working at a European level is important but that's not a long-term comment the Commissioner is due to report back to ECOFIN on the Thursday and Friday of budget week. I want to say in relation to, and you've put forward and your party have put forward proposals in relation to how to help people through this winter period and beyond in terms of how to help people with their energy costs. What I'm saying is there will be an energy package in the budget. There will be some temporary measures to help people with the here and now with this winter but there also needs to be, and I agree on this point, there also needs to be some measures to help people more permanently. The details of that are for budget day but you did hear the Minister for Energy yesterday give an indication of a number of proposals that he intends to bring forward around battery storage and also the scheme he intends to bring forward in relation to a scrappage scheme for boilers. I do think we're seeing people go gangbusters quite frankly in relation to solar panels, in relation to EVs. We see it in our own community. We're seeing it in relation to the actual data coming through but we still need to see if there's more we can do to help accelerate that because people are trying to make decisions in the here and now in their own life to reduce their bills. People are full of common sense and we need to make it as easy as possible for them to make those decisions too. So I think there's things we need to do in the party has voted this way too around temporary excise reductions, around what we do on the home heating. The fuel allowance is already I suppose I'd make the point of targeted energy support and that does kick off from next Monday as well but we accept that going into this winter period energy prices is probably the number one concern of the minds of people in this country and we will come forward with a comprehensive package of measures in the budget in 12 days time. Thank you Deputy Whitmore. Thank you very much Tánaiste and I do welcome. I did hear the Minister talk about the battery storage. I think it would have been best if your government previously hadn't removed the battery storage grant in 2022 when Ukraine was invaded. I think that would have assisted. I would also ask Tánaiste that you try to, I know a lot of people have put in solar. There are many hundreds of thousands of people who cannot afford to do it and I think the reality Tánaiste is it's those people that are really struggling. It's the low to middle income earners that are finding it so hard to move away from fossil fuels because they are not getting enough support from government and I would ask rather than throw good money and a hand over a fist at these short-term emergency temporary measures they are incredibly costly and we're left with nothing to show for at the end of the day. If all those billions of euros that were given in energy credits previously, if they were actually doing their job we wouldn't have 340,000 people or 30,000 people in arrears on their electricity bills or 188,000 people in arrears on their gas. It does not work. We need to insulate homes and that includes long-term strategy and long-term investment. Tánaiste please. I agree and then I have a point of difference. I mean firstly I agree that there are lots of people out there that want to make the transition in their own lives and are still finding the gap too large and indeed I was at the ploughing and met the IFA in the IFA tent in relation to this and you know often farmers are pitted against climate action but actually there's so many farmers saying that we want to put solar on our buildings and we need more support through TAM so these are active issues we need to look at. We do need to do both though and we do need to help with the here and now too and what I would just say to people right across the country is the measures that we help or be they classified as temporary in terms of somewhat suppress the growth in energy prices have a positive inflationary effect on the economy so officials and economists in my department estimate that the measures we've put in place to help reduce energy prices somewhat with the excise reductions and the likes certainly hasn't been wasted measures has actually kept down inflation by around 0.6 percent so when someone's shopping in the supermarket tonight with their basket of goods that those that food would have cost about 0.6 percent higher more on their bill had we not taken these measures so we need to do but I fully accept that we're facing the second energy shock in the European Union in half a decade.