Richard O'Donoghue: Let the People Decide on the Triple Lock
Richard O'Donoghue argues that any removal of the triple lock and any change to Ireland's neutrality must be decided openly and by conscience vote, not by party leaders. He contrasts Independent Ireland's free vote policy with party discipline in Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael and says representation requires listening to the people.
Richard O'Donoghue says the Independent Ireland Party exists to give independents a platform while protecting the vote of conscience. He insists removing the triple lock is a matter for every representative and, by extension, the people of Ireland - not a decision imposed by party whips.
O'Donoghue contrasts Independent Ireland with Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael, arguing those parties enforce instructions from leadership rather than allowing members to vote according to their communities. He points to recent protests as evidence that many people feel unheard and underrepresented by party-led decisions.
He affirms that investing in and equipping Ireland's defence forces is necessary, but stresses that neutrality is not weakness - it is independence. Any alteration to neutrality or the triple lock should be subject to open debate and conscience votes across the House.
The speech frames the debate over the triple lock as a question of democratic representation and individual conscience. O'Donoghue calls for decisions affecting neutrality and defence to be taken transparently, so elected representatives can reflect the views of their constituents.
Main argument
Richard O'Donoghue says the Independent Ireland Party exists to give independents a platform while protecting the vote of conscience. He insists removing the triple lock is a matter for every representative and, by extension, the people of Ireland - not a decision imposed by party whips.
Party discipline versus conscience
O'Donoghue contrasts Independent Ireland with Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael, arguing those parties enforce instructions from leadership rather than allowing members to vote according to their communities. He points to recent protests as evidence that many people feel unheard and underrepresented by party-led decisions.
Neutrality and defence
He affirms that investing in and equipping Ireland's defence forces is necessary, but stresses that neutrality is not weakness - it is independence. Any alteration to neutrality or the triple lock should be subject to open debate and conscience votes across the House.
Implications
The speech frames the debate over the triple lock as a question of democratic representation and individual conscience. O'Donoghue calls for decisions affecting neutrality and defence to be taken transparently, so elected representatives can reflect the views of their constituents.
We publish thousands of recordings to make Irish politics transparent and resistant to manipulation. Spotted an error? Report it — together we are building a reliable archive of Irish politics.
Other speeches
Tego samego dnia All speeches from this day →
Richard Boyd Barrett
Richard Boyd Barrett: Defend Ireland's Neutrality Now
Lynn Boylan
Lynn Boylan: Prioritise Families, Not Militarisation
Brian Stanley
Brian Stanley: Halt the Defence Amendment Bill, Defend Neutrality
Kathleen Funchion
Kathleen Funchion: End the Unfair Carers Means Test
Martin Daly
Martin Daly: Doctor Exodus, Safe Staffing and Broken Hospital IT
Danny Healy-Rae
Danny Healy-Rae demands urgent deer cull in Kerry
Transcript
Minister, Independent Ireland Party was set up for one reason. It was to give a platform for independents to work together. But what's the difference between Independent Ireland and Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael? We have a vote of conscience. And removing the triple lock is a vote of conscience. And it's a vote for the people of Ireland. It should not be up to your party leaders. And anything such as removing a triple lock should be an open vote in this house for your party. At a minimum. You no longer have the full representation of Ireland. You don't have it. Look at your numbers. At the recent protest when people came out there, what happened? He talked down to the real people of Ireland and ignored them. So you no longer represent the people of Ireland as a whole. Neutrality is not a weakness. It's independence. Do we need to invest in our defence forces? 100%. Do we need to put our defence forces so we can protect this country? 100%. But we also need any removal of any triple lock has to be voiced by every person in this country. It is not something that you should have the control of. That's why Independent Ireland put into its policies and its constitution a vote of conscience. That means that people in Independent Ireland, while we might agree on 90% of things, there's 10% we will never agree on. But it allows the person to make that individual choice because they represent different parts of the country and different people in their areas. That's the difference between an Independent Ireland party and Fianna Fáil and Fianna Gael. You're told what to do. Yes, sir. No, sir. Three bags full, sir. That's what you go with. Why not recognise the people of Ireland and let them make the decision. Any alteration to our neutrality, any alteration to triple lock is a voice for the people to make, not a choice for you to make.