Menu
VideoParliament
VideoParliament Irish politics in one place — download the app
Get app
VideoParliament
VideoParliament for Windows Get the desktop app — notifications about new speeches
Get app
Paul Murphy: Warns of Collison Brothers' Threat to Democracy

Paul Murphy: Warns of Collison Brothers' Threat to Democracy

Paul Murphy argues that modest amendments to reinstate democratic oversight are being blocked because the Bill aims to remove democratic input from the planning system. He names the Collison Brothers and the neo-libertarian think tank Progress Ireland as driving a corporate agenda that will prioritise data centres and energy interests over public control.

Allegations of undue influence


Paul Murphy details how, in his view, the Collison Brothers have developed undue influence over government policy via Progress Ireland. He links earlier planning relaxations - such as easing permissions for garden cabins - to a broader campaign now seeking to limit democratic oversight of planning decisions.

Impact on energy and planning


Murphy warns the practical consequence will be a surge in data centres that drive up household electricity costs and soak up renewable generation. He also says the campaign paves the way for normalising nuclear power and shifts control of infrastructure decisions away from local democratic checks.

International connections and ideology


The speech traces ideological ties between Progress Ireland and international libertarian think tanks, naming organisations and figures criticised by Murphy. He places these links in the context of a neoliberal, pro-market agenda he believes is being promoted in Ireland.

Political stakes and appeal


Murphy calls out Fianna Fáil, Fine Gael and certain independents for supporting the Bill and urges public attention to what he calls a corporate takeover. He frames the modest amendment as an essential, incremental step to preserve democratic oversight of planning decisions.

We publish thousands of recordings to make Irish politics transparent and resistant to manipulation. Spotted an error? Report it — together we are building a reliable archive of Irish politics.

Tego samego dnia All speeches from this day →

Transcript
Thanks a lot, Ciann Comhairle. I think these are very modest amendments reinstituting some form of democratic oversight. I presume the government is going to oppose them because the whole purpose of the Bill from the government's perspective is to gut democratic oversight, to gut democratic input into the planning system. And I think the public should know where this is coming from. The Collison Brothers, two filthy rich Irish billionaires, have developed a seriously undue influence over the Irish government via the neo-libertarian think tank, Progress Ireland. First it was changing the law to allow landlords to rent out beds in sheds by getting rid of planning permission for cabins in back gardens. And now they are driving this Bill to gut democratic input into the planning system. So what tech billionaires see as critical infrastructure can bypass normal democratic checks and balances. And now presumably you're going to oppose a modicum of democratic oversight as proposed by these amendments. It doesn't take a genius to know what this is going to mean. It's going to mean data centres. Driving up household electricity costs even higher, hoovering up all the renewables that are added to the grid, just like they've been doing over the past 10 years. The next item on their agenda is normalising nuclear power. The mindless parrots over on the government benches are singing along to that tune now too. The last we heard of the Collisons was jogging through Tel Aviv tweeting that it's great to be back during a genocide. The Zionists are disciples of the notorious Koch brothers. For decades they have bankrolled the astroturf, far-right, neoliberal and libertarian causes around the world, including Javier Millet in Argentina, climate denialism and of course Donald Trump. 90 year old Charles Koch, the closest thing to a real life Mr Burns off the Simpsons is an idol for these people. Last summer Patrick Collison gave a keynote address at a gathering of libertarians in Washington DC where he eulogised Charles Koch as inspirational. The Ayn Rand Institute, the Cato Institute, the Adam Smith Institute, the Mercatus Centre, all of these shadowy Koch-funded right-wing think tanks are co-thinkers and fellow travellers of Progress Ireland with a thousand ties that bind them together. It's genuinely scary stuff that is coming here and again the government is going to oppose this amendment which is about some modicum of democratic oversight. Progress Ireland's innovation policy lead Sam Enright recently hosted a conference to discuss whether Milton Friedman was the greatest economist of all time. The fact that he was the architect of Pinochet's neoliberal reforms in Chile, which would only be enforced by a military coup and a brutal dictatorship during which an estimated 40,000 people were tortured, is no problem for these guys. If anything, as the Collison's attitude to Israel shows, it's probably a plus. When Progress Ireland launched an appeal for funding they bragged that, quote, Ireland is highly conformist and is more prone to deference to elite or expert consensus than our British counterparts. That was said to be a positive, right? That was said to be a positive in their pitch for funding. I'm making this speech to warn anyone who's watching that what we're experiencing right now is a key moment of corporate takeover. Fianna Fáil, Fine Gael, the right-wing independents are lapping it up like the corporate lapdogs that they are. We have to wake up and stop the Collison's before it's too late. This amendment is a very small step towards doing that.