Holly Cairns: Bill to End Barriers to Abortion Care
Holly Cairns (Social Democrats) introduces a bill today to remove the mandatory three-day waiting period and begin decriminalisation of abortion in Ireland. She argues the current law still forces women to travel abroad, creates stigma, and places clinicians under legal threat.
Holly Cairns sets out a Bill grounded in the principle that women deserve compassionate, timely, evidence-based healthcare. The Bill would stop mandatory delays, offer an optional reflection period, and start the work to treat abortion as healthcare rather than a criminal offence.
Cairns cites the case of Denise Whitmore, who nearly died travelling to England after a fatal foetal diagnosis and was advised to smuggle her daughter home in the boot of a car. The speech frames current law as producing trauma for grieving families and forcing people onto planes and ferries to access care.
Cairns points to the Government's own O'Shea review from three years ago, IFPA research showing 98% return rates after waiting periods, and World Health Organization guidance that mandatory waiting periods create barriers. She says the three-day rule has no medical basis and can push women beyond legal limits.
The speech challenges the continued criminal sanction for clinicians - up to 14 years' imprisonment - and stresses that decriminalisation would not mean deregulation. Cairns calls for safeguards, professional standards and medical ethics to govern care, not the threat of criminal penalties.
Cairns urges members to allow the Bill to proceed to committee stage so experts, clinicians and advocates can test and improve legislation. She frames the Bill as the start of reform, responding to gaps identified in the O'Shea review and the lived consequences for women still waiting for change.
Summary of the proposal
Holly Cairns sets out a Bill grounded in the principle that women deserve compassionate, timely, evidence-based healthcare. The Bill would stop mandatory delays, offer an optional reflection period, and start the work to treat abortion as healthcare rather than a criminal offence.
Personal stories and human cost
Cairns cites the case of Denise Whitmore, who nearly died travelling to England after a fatal foetal diagnosis and was advised to smuggle her daughter home in the boot of a car. The speech frames current law as producing trauma for grieving families and forcing people onto planes and ferries to access care.
Medical evidence and expert review
Cairns points to the Government's own O'Shea review from three years ago, IFPA research showing 98% return rates after waiting periods, and World Health Organization guidance that mandatory waiting periods create barriers. She says the three-day rule has no medical basis and can push women beyond legal limits.
Criminalisation and regulation
The speech challenges the continued criminal sanction for clinicians - up to 14 years' imprisonment - and stresses that decriminalisation would not mean deregulation. Cairns calls for safeguards, professional standards and medical ethics to govern care, not the threat of criminal penalties.
Next steps and parliamentary process
Cairns urges members to allow the Bill to proceed to committee stage so experts, clinicians and advocates can test and improve legislation. She frames the Bill as the start of reform, responding to gaps identified in the O'Shea review and the lived consequences for women still waiting for change.
We publish thousands of recordings to make Irish politics transparent and resistant to manipulation. Spotted an error? Report it — together we are building a reliable archive of Irish politics.
Other speeches
Tego samego dnia All speeches from this day →
Grace Boland
Grace Boland: Urges Evidence-Based Review of 2018 Act
Gerard P. Craughwell
Gerard P. Craughwell Questions H145 Helicopter Purchase and Safety
Michael Fitzmaurice
Michael Fitzmaurice: Habitats Directive is blocking projects
Brian Brennan
Brian Brennan on Wind Turbine Regulation Bill 2025: Villages at Risk
Malcolm Byrne
Malcolm Byrne: Flexibility is Ireland's Cheapest Energy Fix
Mattie McGrath
Mattie McGrath: Shannon abstraction '2%' claim challenged
Transcript
Eight years ago, Ireland voted overwhelmingly to repeal the Eighth Amendment. People voted for compassion. They voted to end the cruelty of forcing women onto planes and ferries. They voted because we believe that women should be able to access abortion here, at home, with their families, doctors and support systems around them. While enormous progress has been made since then, the promise of repeal has not been fully realised. Many women who receive devastating diagnoses of fatal events, often after the 20-week scan, are still being forced to make that long, lonely journey to the UK. The mandatory three-day waiting period continues to create unnecessary distress and delay, despite having absolutely no medical basis. And the continued criminalisation of abortion creates fear among clinicians and stigma for patients. These issues were all identified in the Government's own expert review of the law three years ago. Yet three years later, women are still waiting. This is why the Social Democrats are bringing forward this Bill today. A Bill based on a very simple principle. Women deserve compassionate, timely, evidenced-based healthcare. Not stigma. Not shame. Not barriers. Healthcare. A few weeks ago, at Leaders' Questions, I raised the case of Denise Whitmore, who nearly died travelling to England for a termination after receiving a fatal foetal diagnosis. After everything they had already endured, Denise and her husband, Mark, were advised to smuggle their daughter, Ada, home in the boot of their car so they could bring her home to Ireland. That is the result of our current legislation. Grieving parents made to feel like criminals for wanting to bring their daughter home. That is not what Ireland voted for in 2018. As legislators, we do not get to look away from the reality because it is uncomfortable or complicated. We are the only people in this country with the power to fix laws that are causing harm. Right now, our law only permits a termination where the condition is likely to lead to the death of the foetus before birth or within 28 days of birth. Doctors, families and advocacy groups have repeatedly told us this threshold is too narrow and too rigid. Doctors are being placed in impossible positions and women are still travelling as a result. The mandatory three-day waiting period is another example of a barrier that exists not because of medicine but because of politics and, once again, it is women who pay the price. The World Health Organisation has been very explicit that mandatory waiting periods create barriers to care and should be removed because women are capable of making decisions about our own healthcare. We know from the IFPA research that 98% of women return after the three days. So what is the law actually achieving? It's not improving healthcare. It's not protecting women. In some cases, it is pushing women beyond the 12-week limit entirely, forcing them to travel abroad again. This bill would instead make a reflection period available to any woman who wants more time but would no longer force women who have already made up their minds to delay their care. We also need to talk honestly about criminalisation. The World Health Organisation is clear that abortion should be fully decriminalised and treated as healthcare, yet in Ireland healthcare professionals can still face up to 14 years' imprisonment. That matters because criminalisation creates a chilling effect where doctors must consider legal risk rather than focusing solely on their patient. Decriminalisation does not mean deregulation. There will be safeguards, there will be accountability, doctors will still be governed by professional standards and medical ethics, but healthcare should be regulated as healthcare, not through the threat of criminal sanction. I'm asking members across this House not to close their minds to this legislation before the work has even begun. Allow this bill to move to committee stage, because committee stage is where we can do our best work, where we hear from experts, clinicians, where we test legislation, improve legislation and strengthen legislation. This bill isn't the final product, it's the start of improving a system we know is failing too many women. The gaps in our law were identified three years ago in the O'Shea review. Women are still living with the consequences of our failure to act, and they deserve better.