Paul Murphy: Retrofitting failing - 92-year-old left exposed
Paul Murphy addresses the Dail, urging urgent and expanded retrofitting to tackle the cost of living and climate crises. He warns that the government's privatised model is creating serious problems, and gives constituency examples including a 92-year-old who received poor-quality work during Storm Chandra.
Immediate concern: constituency cases
Paul Murphy details local examples from his constituency to illustrate systemic failures in the retrofitting rollout. He cites a 92-year-old widow who received a 100% grant for wraparound external wall insulation that was installed during Storm Chandra. Murphy says she sought help from the SAI and "got absolutely nowhere."
Problems with the privatised model
Murphy argues the government's privatised approach to retrofitting is generating avoidable harms and administrative dead ends. He highlights cases where contractors failed to provide necessary declarations and where applicants face denial or unresolved complaints.
Remedies and routes for redress
Murphy urges faster, larger-scale retrofitting and calls for affected households to be supported through the one-stop shop and for the companies involved to be engaged. He stresses that retrofitting is part of the solution to both the cost of living crisis and the climate crisis and demands accountability for botched installations.
Political exchange and follow-up
During the exchange, Murphy invites further engagement from deputies and officials, noting specific instances where grants should be recovered and cases should be reopened. He frames the issue as both a practical and moral failure that needs immediate correction.
We publish thousands of recordings to make Irish politics transparent and resistant to manipulation. Spotted an error? Report it — together we are building a reliable archive of Irish politics.
Thanks, Ciann Comhairle. Taoiseach, we need retrofitting as quickly and as much as possible. It's the answer to, or it's part of the answer to the cost of living crisis and the climate crisis. Problem is the way the government has gone about it with your privatised model is now beginning to result in significant problems. I'll give you a few examples from my constituency. Filomena Doran, a 92-year-old widow in Oldbourne, she got a 100% grant to get a wraparound external wall insulation. But the external wall insulation was put on during Storm Chandra when the building advice says clearly you can't put it on during, when it is raining. She went to the SAI, got absolutely nowhere. Another woman who got in touch whereby they didn't provide the necessary declaration called Clare Hayes for her to get the grant. Everybody's been treated the same. Deputy Conor D. McGuinness. Deputy, I did that, I think. That's the retrofitting. I didn't quite get the import of what you were saying in terms of one person not being able to get the grant back because it was wrongly... You'll have to engage further, no deputy. Deputy. Yeah, it shouldn't have been, yeah, but I mean, if you can, I, you know, that's a specific case. They should get it back. And I think the one-stop shop should be approached. You can engage further. To engage with the company involved. Deputy McGuinness.
Thank you for downloading 🙏
If you publish this material on social media, we would be very grateful if you tagged VideoParliament. It helps us reach more people and keep building a transparent archive of Irish politics.