Menu
VideoParliament
VideoParliament Irish politics in one place — download the app
Get app
VideoParliament
VideoParliament for Windows Get the desktop app — notifications about new speeches
Get app
Joanna Byrne: The State Must Fund Dignity for Patients

Joanna Byrne: The State Must Fund Dignity for Patients

Joanna Byrne speaks from Leinster House urging the government to provide urgent funding and support to Dignity for Patients after survivors of convicted abuser Michael Shine gave testimony. She recounts decades of complaints dating back to 1964, praises whistleblower Bernadette Sullivan, and says the state has a duty of care.

Remarks from Leinster House


Joanna Byrne hosted Dignity for Patients in Leinster House and acknowledged five survivors - Larry, Keenan, Gerard, Peter and Ian - who spoke about abuse by Michael Shine. Byrne said survivors delivered a shared message: truth matters and transparency matters, and she thanked them for their bravery and trust.

Historical context and whistleblower


Byrne outlined the timeline of complaints and reports about Michael Shine, noting reports as early as 1964 and further documentation through the 1970s and 1980s, with allegations that the abuse was an open secret at Our Lady of Lords Hospital in Drogheda. She highlighted the 1995 complaint by Bernadette Sullivan, calling her not merely a whistleblower but a hero for exposing Shine.

Immediate demands and consequences


While welcoming the scope and inquiry, Byrne said the exercise exposed a lack of capacity to support victims. She urged the government to fund Dignity for Patients now, including an advocacy worker that the organisation has requested and already put a business case forward for. Byrne stressed the state has a duty of care and that answers are still sought in 2026.

Support for survivors


Byrne described Dignity for Patients as a lifeline for Drogheda and beyond, noting they have supported over 400 vulnerable people with only two advocacy team members. She reassured viewers affected by similar abuse that Dignity for Patients operates a helpline Monday to Thursday, 10 a.m. to 4 p.m., and encouraged anyone who needs support to reach out.

We publish thousands of recordings to make Irish politics transparent and resistant to manipulation. Spotted an error? Report it — together we are building a reliable archive of Irish politics.

Tego samego dnia All speeches from this day →

Transcript
Just over a year ago, I had the privilege to host Dignity for Patients here in Leinster House, where five courageous survivors of convicted sexual abuse, or Michael Shine, shared their testimonies with TD centres and political staff. Survivors Larry, Keenan, Gerard, Peter and Ian spoke with one voice on behalf of the hundreds of known victims who had come forward and their message was clear, truth matters and transparency matters. Complaints and reports of sexual abuse from Michael Shine were first made to hospital authorities as early as 1964, with more documented reports throughout the 70s and 80s. Victims have stated that this was an open secret at Our Lady of Lords Hospital in Drogheda, but nobody batted an eyelid. And then in 1995, Bernadette Sullivan, a nurse, stepped forward and made a formal complaint and this was the beginning of Michael Shine's well overdue downfall and exposure as the most prolific paedophile in Europe. She's been called a whistleblower, she is in fact a hero. The wheels of justice turn slowly and that is why in 2026 we are still looking for answers. Today I want to acknowledge the immense pain and trauma that survivors of Michael Shine have endured, the long and difficult path they have walked with Dignity for Patients in their fight for truth and justice, their positive engagement with the scope and inquiry and their ongoing campaign for public inquiry. The government must also support them to rebuild their lives. Through my own local engagement with survivors and their families, I know how important the support provided by Dignity for Patients is. The people of Drogheda and beyond rightly view this as a lifeline. While the scope and exercise was an important and welcome step, it also exposed the lack of capacity to support victims and survivors and adequate funding and resources must now be provided to Dignity for Patients by the government ahead of any potential next steps that follow this exercise. It's mind-boggling that they haven't been provided with funding for an advocacy worker despite submitting a business case for this, particularly when they have supported over 400 vulnerable people and brave survivors with only two advocacy team members. The state has a duty of care to survivors like Larry, like Keenan, like Jared, like Peter, like Ian and many more like them. On a personal level, I'm proud to personally know these men, immensely proud of their bravery, and I want to thank them for trusting me with their painful experience. I'd just like to reassure anybody out there that's watching this today who has been affected similarly that there is a helpline ongoing by Dignity for Patients Monday to Thursday 10 a.m to 4 p.m and there's people there to listen and support them. Thank you.