Conor D McGuinness challenged the Taoiseach over Ireland's response to Israel's actions and questioned whether Germany is blocking EU steps to suspend the EU-Israel trade agreement. He pressed for movement on the Occupied Territories Bill and for Ireland to introduce real sanctions rather than delay.
Direct challenge to government action
Conor D McGuinness confronted the Taoiseach in the Dail, saying there have been no domestic sanctions, no EU leadership and no meaningful consequences from Ireland for Israel's conduct. He cited recent high-level contacts between Ireland and Germany and pointed to unilateral steps taken by Spain and Italy as proof action is possible.
Taoiseach's response and diplomatic context
The Taoiseach replied that he has engaged with the German Chancellor and others to persuade them, noting Germany's historic perspective on the Middle East and its strong humanitarian contributions. He also acknowledged concerns about Israeli behaviour in Gaza and Lebanon while defending ongoing diplomatic engagement.
Policy implications and next steps
McGuinness urged the government to set a timetable for the Occupied Territories Bill and to adopt concrete sanctions rather than continued delay. The exchange frames a broader debate on Ireland's ability to coordinate EU action, the role of Germany in European diplomacy, and how the government balances humanitarian concerns with accountability.
We publish thousands of recordings to make Irish politics transparent and resistant to manipulation. Spotted an error? Report it — together we are building a reliable archive of Irish politics.
Comhairle, Taoiseach, it's a number of months since the Economic Forum in Davos, but in the past four nights you've met the German Chancellor, we've had the German Foreign Minister here in Dublin, yet we now know that Germany has once again blocked even the most modest EU action to suspend the EU-Israel trade agreement, an agreement that grants preferential access to a state, to a rogue state, that is systematically violating international law, human rights norms and the very terms of that agreement. At the same time, countries like Spain and Italy have taken unilateral steps and they've shown that action is possible. Your government has done neither. No domestic sanctions, no leadership at EU level, no meaningful consequences from Ireland for Israel's actions, for its brazen contraventions of international law, for its genocide, Taoiseach. So I want to ask you directly, have you challenged Germany's position and its role in shielding Israel from accountability? Will you move on the Occupied Territories Bill and when will this government finally take even the most basic, moderate steps of introducing real sanctions rather than continuing a policy of delay and inaction? Deputy Rose Conroy-Walsh. And in terms of Deputy McGuinness, again, Ireland has taken steps with Spain. The way you present the Ireland position on the Middle East just defies what actually has happened. And when I met President Mustafa, all he said to me was thank you for Ireland's stance. So I think we should listen to the Palestinian representatives and Palestinians generally who are very appreciative of the efforts of the Irish government and the Irish people towards their situation. I have engaged with the German Chancellor and others to try and persuade people. Germany has a particular historic perspective in respect of the Middle East and that has governed their position in relation to it. But they're very strong, to be fair to them, on the humanitarian side and they probably give more than most in terms of contributions on that front. But there is an issue and the issue I discussed it only recently at the Council last week in terms of the Israeli behavior in Gaza but also in Lebanon.
Thank you for downloading 🙏
If you publish this material on social media, we would be very grateful if you tagged VideoParliament. It helps us reach more people and keep building a transparent archive of Irish politics.
